"The wine of youth does not always clear with advancing years; sometimes it grows turbid"
About this Quote
Jung’s line lands like a polite toast that curdles on the tongue. Youth is usually sold as a vintage that matures into wisdom; he flips the bottle and shows the sediment. “Wine” is doing double duty: it evokes intoxication (youth as blissful delusion) and fermentation (youth as raw material that should, ideally, refine). The sting is in “does not always.” Jung isn’t denying growth; he’s rejecting the comforting story that time automatically clarifies the self.
The subtext is clinical and slightly merciless: maturation is not guaranteed, and the psyche can thicken as it ages. The “turbid” years aren’t just disappointment or bitterness; they’re the return of what was never metabolized. In Jungian terms, this is the shadow and the unlived life: early defenses harden into personality, youthful ideals ossify into moral vanity, wounds become identity. People don’t simply lose innocence; they can lose permeability, the capacity to revise themselves.
Context matters. Jung wrote in a Europe watching progress mythologies collapse into mechanized war and mass ideology. The modern project promised that education, reason, and time would make us better. Jung, watching patients and nations, saw something else: regression, projection, and an uncanny ability for adults to remain emotionally adolescent while gaining power.
Why it works is its quiet refusal to flatter. It’s an image you can’t argue with. Everyone has met the aging person whose inner weather has grown cloudier, not clearer. Jung turns that observation into a warning: if you don’t do the work, years don’t polish you; they concentrate you.
The subtext is clinical and slightly merciless: maturation is not guaranteed, and the psyche can thicken as it ages. The “turbid” years aren’t just disappointment or bitterness; they’re the return of what was never metabolized. In Jungian terms, this is the shadow and the unlived life: early defenses harden into personality, youthful ideals ossify into moral vanity, wounds become identity. People don’t simply lose innocence; they can lose permeability, the capacity to revise themselves.
Context matters. Jung wrote in a Europe watching progress mythologies collapse into mechanized war and mass ideology. The modern project promised that education, reason, and time would make us better. Jung, watching patients and nations, saw something else: regression, projection, and an uncanny ability for adults to remain emotionally adolescent while gaining power.
Why it works is its quiet refusal to flatter. It’s an image you can’t argue with. Everyone has met the aging person whose inner weather has grown cloudier, not clearer. Jung turns that observation into a warning: if you don’t do the work, years don’t polish you; they concentrate you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Aging |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Carl
Add to List







