"The wretched have no compassion, they can do good only from strong principles of duty"
About this Quote
Cruelty, Johnson implies, is often less a moral choice than a symptom: misery curdles the instincts that make kindness feel natural. "The wretched have no compassion" is deliberately bracing, almost prosecutorial, because it refuses a comforting story that suffering automatically ennobles. He’s arguing the opposite: deprivation narrows the imagination, makes other people’s pain feel like competition, not kinship. That’s a bleak view of human nature, but it’s also an ethical provocation aimed at the comfortable reader who romanticizes hardship from a safe distance.
The second clause does the real work. If the wretched "can do good only from strong principles of duty", then goodness becomes less an emotion than a discipline. Johnson, a deeply moral writer shaped by Christian ethics and a lifetime of financial strain and melancholia, is outlining a theory of virtue that doesn’t depend on mood. Compassion is unreliable when you’re hungry, ashamed, exhausted. Duty - internalized, almost muscle-memory - can still operate when empathy is offline.
Subtextually, it’s both a warning and a demand. Don’t expect the poor to be saints; build a society that doesn’t force people into moral triage. And if you yourself are suffering, don’t wait to "feel" generous. Act from principle. Johnson’s line has the sting of lived experience: he’s not flattering the downtrodden, he’s respecting them enough to say virtue under pressure is hard - and therefore requires structure, habit, and obligations that outlast sentiment.
The second clause does the real work. If the wretched "can do good only from strong principles of duty", then goodness becomes less an emotion than a discipline. Johnson, a deeply moral writer shaped by Christian ethics and a lifetime of financial strain and melancholia, is outlining a theory of virtue that doesn’t depend on mood. Compassion is unreliable when you’re hungry, ashamed, exhausted. Duty - internalized, almost muscle-memory - can still operate when empathy is offline.
Subtextually, it’s both a warning and a demand. Don’t expect the poor to be saints; build a society that doesn’t force people into moral triage. And if you yourself are suffering, don’t wait to "feel" generous. Act from principle. Johnson’s line has the sting of lived experience: he’s not flattering the downtrodden, he’s respecting them enough to say virtue under pressure is hard - and therefore requires structure, habit, and obligations that outlast sentiment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List











