"Their chief residence was Bagdad, where they remained until the eleventh century, an age fatal in Oriental history, from the disasters of which the Princes of the Captivity were not exempt"
About this Quote
Bagdad is doing double duty here: a concrete seat of power and a shorthand for a whole civilizational mood swing. Disraeli’s phrasing has the cool, clerkly poise of an antiquarian, but the sentence is loaded with judgment. “An age fatal in Oriental history” doesn’t just date events; it sentences a millennium. The word “fatal” implies inevitability, as if the eleventh century weren’t a knot of political fractures, invasions, and shifting religious authority so much as a predestined collapse. That’s not neutral history-writing; it’s a narrative device that lets the author convert complexity into a moral arc.
The “Princes of the Captivity” carries its own resonance: the Jewish exilarchs, leaders of a community living under empire, simultaneously privileged and precarious. Disraeli frames them as exceptions that prove the rule of decline. “Were not exempt” is the kicker. It suggests a kind of historical weather system that sweeps up everyone, even the supposedly insulated elites. The subtext is both fatalistic and implicitly comparative: “Oriental history” becomes a category where catastrophe is the defining feature, a familiar move in early 19th-century British letters that treated the East as an arena of grand, recurring breakdown rather than contested, adaptive continuity.
It works because it feels like sober chronicle while smuggling in a worldview: empires decay, the East decays especially, and minority leadership is ultimately hostage to the larger political tide. The sentence’s authority comes from its calmness; the bias comes from how easily “fatal” replaces explanation.
The “Princes of the Captivity” carries its own resonance: the Jewish exilarchs, leaders of a community living under empire, simultaneously privileged and precarious. Disraeli frames them as exceptions that prove the rule of decline. “Were not exempt” is the kicker. It suggests a kind of historical weather system that sweeps up everyone, even the supposedly insulated elites. The subtext is both fatalistic and implicitly comparative: “Oriental history” becomes a category where catastrophe is the defining feature, a familiar move in early 19th-century British letters that treated the East as an arena of grand, recurring breakdown rather than contested, adaptive continuity.
It works because it feels like sober chronicle while smuggling in a worldview: empires decay, the East decays especially, and minority leadership is ultimately hostage to the larger political tide. The sentence’s authority comes from its calmness; the bias comes from how easily “fatal” replaces explanation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Tough Times |
|---|
More Quotes by Isaac
Add to List
