"Their way of Dancing, is nothing but a sort of stamping Motion, much like the treading upon Founders Bellows"
About this Quote
Lawson’s sentence lands with the blunt force of a boot: Native dance reduced to “nothing but” noise and mechanics, a “stamping Motion” likened to “treading upon Founders Bellows.” It’s not just a description; it’s a demotion. By reaching for an image from the colonial workshop, he translates an unfamiliar ritual into something he can file under labor, utility, and crude impact. The comparison is doing ideological work: it turns music into machinery and ceremony into mere percussion, a rhythmic practice reframed as mindless exertion.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, Lawson is reporting what he sees as an observer-explorer trying to make the New World legible to readers back home. Underneath, he’s performing cultural triage. The phrase “nothing but” signals that the baseline assumption is European dance as refinement, elevation, art; everything else is a lesser cousin. “Founders Bellows” also drags the scene into the forge, evoking heat, metal, and production. Indigenous bodies become tools that generate force rather than people generating meaning.
Context matters: early 18th-century travel writing often blended ethnography with salesmanship for empire. Lawson’s eye is practical, inventory-like, built for sponsors, settlers, and curious London readers. That audience didn’t just want vividness; it wanted reassurance that difference could be managed. Describing dance as a kind of industrial stomping quietly supports a larger colonial logic: if a culture can be rendered as crude motion, it can be dismissed, corrected, or replaced.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, Lawson is reporting what he sees as an observer-explorer trying to make the New World legible to readers back home. Underneath, he’s performing cultural triage. The phrase “nothing but” signals that the baseline assumption is European dance as refinement, elevation, art; everything else is a lesser cousin. “Founders Bellows” also drags the scene into the forge, evoking heat, metal, and production. Indigenous bodies become tools that generate force rather than people generating meaning.
Context matters: early 18th-century travel writing often blended ethnography with salesmanship for empire. Lawson’s eye is practical, inventory-like, built for sponsors, settlers, and curious London readers. That audience didn’t just want vividness; it wanted reassurance that difference could be managed. Describing dance as a kind of industrial stomping quietly supports a larger colonial logic: if a culture can be rendered as crude motion, it can be dismissed, corrected, or replaced.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List








