"There are moments when you feel free, moments when you have energy, moments when you have hope, but you can't rely on any of these things to see you through. Circumstances do that"
About this Quote
Brookner’s line lands like a quiet correction to the self-help century: the idea that your interior weather will save you is, at best, intermittent. She stacks the good feelings - freedom, energy, hope - as “moments,” a word that shrinks them to flickers. The repetition is almost soothing, then she snaps it shut with “but you can’t rely,” a phrase with the chill of lived experience. What keeps you going isn’t a heroic mood; it’s the blunt machinery of “circumstances.”
That last sentence is the sting. “Circumstances do that” is deliberately flat, even faintly bureaucratic. It denies the romantic narrative in which perseverance is an attitude you summon on command. Brookner, a historian by training and a novelist of social constraint by temperament, is pointing to the forces that outlast willpower: money, work, other people’s needs, illness, obligation, routine. Circumstances “see you through” the way a current carries a swimmer - not because it’s kind, but because it’s stronger than you.
The subtext is both bleak and oddly consoling. If hope is unreliable, you’re not failing when it evaporates. You’re simply human in a world where conditions, not convictions, determine the next hour. Brookner’s intent isn’t to shame emotion but to demote it: feelings are real, vivid, and temporary; structure is what persists. It’s an adult statement about survival, stripped of drama, trusting the reader to recognize that endurance often looks like compliance with the day’s demands rather than a triumphant inner glow.
That last sentence is the sting. “Circumstances do that” is deliberately flat, even faintly bureaucratic. It denies the romantic narrative in which perseverance is an attitude you summon on command. Brookner, a historian by training and a novelist of social constraint by temperament, is pointing to the forces that outlast willpower: money, work, other people’s needs, illness, obligation, routine. Circumstances “see you through” the way a current carries a swimmer - not because it’s kind, but because it’s stronger than you.
The subtext is both bleak and oddly consoling. If hope is unreliable, you’re not failing when it evaporates. You’re simply human in a world where conditions, not convictions, determine the next hour. Brookner’s intent isn’t to shame emotion but to demote it: feelings are real, vivid, and temporary; structure is what persists. It’s an adult statement about survival, stripped of drama, trusting the reader to recognize that endurance often looks like compliance with the day’s demands rather than a triumphant inner glow.
Quote Details
| Topic | Resilience |
|---|
More Quotes by Anita
Add to List





