"There are no enemies in science, professor. Only phenomena to study"
About this Quote
Science, in Lederer’s line, isn’t a cathedral of pure reason so much as a discipline that refuses the cheap pleasure of a villain. “There are no enemies” is a rebuke to a very human reflex: to turn uncertainty into combat, to moralize what we don’t understand, to recruit the unknown into a narrative where someone must be at fault. The word “professor” sharpens the blade. It’s not aimed at the ignorant public; it’s aimed at the educated ego, the kind that can smuggle pride and rivalry into the lab and call it rigor.
As a screenwriter, Lederer knows the seduction of adversaries. Stories run on conflict; people become legible when they’re opposed. This line flips that instinct into a credo: the scientist’s job is to downgrade hostility into curiosity. “Only phenomena to study” sounds almost cold, but that chill is the point. It’s emotional self-control dressed up as method. The subtext is a warning about what happens when science adopts the posture of war: research becomes crusade, dissent becomes treason, and nature itself gets framed as an enemy to defeat rather than a system to understand.
Contextually, it reads like mid-century confidence in expertise with a thin seam of anxiety underneath: a world where discoveries could cure disease or build bombs. Lederer’s intent is not to sanctify science, but to define its best habit of mind: replacing outrage with attention, and replacing personal grievance with observation.
As a screenwriter, Lederer knows the seduction of adversaries. Stories run on conflict; people become legible when they’re opposed. This line flips that instinct into a credo: the scientist’s job is to downgrade hostility into curiosity. “Only phenomena to study” sounds almost cold, but that chill is the point. It’s emotional self-control dressed up as method. The subtext is a warning about what happens when science adopts the posture of war: research becomes crusade, dissent becomes treason, and nature itself gets framed as an enemy to defeat rather than a system to understand.
Contextually, it reads like mid-century confidence in expertise with a thin seam of anxiety underneath: a world where discoveries could cure disease or build bombs. Lederer’s intent is not to sanctify science, but to define its best habit of mind: replacing outrage with attention, and replacing personal grievance with observation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List








