"There are no generalizations in American politics that vested selfishness cannot cut through"
About this Quote
American politics loves a tidy story right up until someone’s revenue stream walks into the room. John Gunther’s line works because it punctures the national addiction to sweeping theories with a blunt, reportorial truth: incentives don’t just complicate ideas; they scalpel them open. “Vested selfishness” is a deliberately ungentle phrase. It doesn’t romanticize interest groups as stakeholders or pluralism as healthy bargaining. It frames self-interest as something with an ownership deed and a blade.
The jab at “generalizations” is also a jab at the commentators and reformers who keep trying to explain the country with one big rule: the will of the people, the march of progress, the arc of history, the party realignment. Gunther, a journalist of the interwar and postwar era, had reason to distrust elegant narratives. Mid-century America was a laboratory of high ideals (New Deal governance, wartime mobilization, Cold War consensus) constantly negotiated down by lobbies, machine politics, and regional power brokers. The subtext: American democracy isn’t uniquely corrupt; it’s uniquely skilled at laundering self-interest through principle.
The sentence is sharp because it’s not cynicism for sport; it’s a warning about how policy gets made. “Cut through” implies speed and efficiency, the way a well-funded, well-placed interest can bypass public mood, party rhetoric, even moral urgency. Gunther isn’t claiming nothing changes. He’s saying the fastest way to predict what will survive the scrum is to ask who’s materially invested in stopping it.
The jab at “generalizations” is also a jab at the commentators and reformers who keep trying to explain the country with one big rule: the will of the people, the march of progress, the arc of history, the party realignment. Gunther, a journalist of the interwar and postwar era, had reason to distrust elegant narratives. Mid-century America was a laboratory of high ideals (New Deal governance, wartime mobilization, Cold War consensus) constantly negotiated down by lobbies, machine politics, and regional power brokers. The subtext: American democracy isn’t uniquely corrupt; it’s uniquely skilled at laundering self-interest through principle.
The sentence is sharp because it’s not cynicism for sport; it’s a warning about how policy gets made. “Cut through” implies speed and efficiency, the way a well-funded, well-placed interest can bypass public mood, party rhetoric, even moral urgency. Gunther isn’t claiming nothing changes. He’s saying the fastest way to predict what will survive the scrum is to ask who’s materially invested in stopping it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List










