"There are rhythmic ideas which sometimes only work up to a point. In writing there are moments when it just comes off the page, it's not just a collection of notes"
About this Quote
Birtwistle is pushing back against the comforting myth that musical meaning is baked into technique. A "rhythmic idea" can be clever, even seductive, and still hit a ceiling: it dazzles as pattern but stalls as drama. The phrase "only work up to a point" is the composer talking like a craftsman who has watched a device lose oxygen in real time. Rhythm, in this view, is not a guarantee of momentum; it can become an engine that revs without moving the car.
The pivot to "writing" is telling. Birtwistle is a modernist who thinks like a dramatist: composition is inscription, a set of decisions that must survive contact with the page and the performer. When he says there are moments when it "just comes off the page", he's naming that elusive threshold where structure becomes event. Not "expressive" in the sentimental sense, but activated: the material stops behaving like an inventory ("a collection of notes") and starts behaving like a force with consequence, something that compels attention because it implies necessity.
Subtext: he's policing his own work, and maybe his peers', against the trap of technique-as-content. Postwar composition often prized systems, grids, and procedures; Birtwistle acknowledges their allure while insisting that the listener doesn't ultimately hear the method, they hear whether the music achieves a lived moment. The context is an aesthetic ethic: craft matters, but only insofar as it produces that click where the page turns into time.
The pivot to "writing" is telling. Birtwistle is a modernist who thinks like a dramatist: composition is inscription, a set of decisions that must survive contact with the page and the performer. When he says there are moments when it "just comes off the page", he's naming that elusive threshold where structure becomes event. Not "expressive" in the sentimental sense, but activated: the material stops behaving like an inventory ("a collection of notes") and starts behaving like a force with consequence, something that compels attention because it implies necessity.
Subtext: he's policing his own work, and maybe his peers', against the trap of technique-as-content. Postwar composition often prized systems, grids, and procedures; Birtwistle acknowledges their allure while insisting that the listener doesn't ultimately hear the method, they hear whether the music achieves a lived moment. The context is an aesthetic ethic: craft matters, but only insofar as it produces that click where the page turns into time.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Harrison
Add to List
