"There are three kinds of intelligence: one kind understands things for itself, the other appreciates what others can understand, the third understands neither for itself nor through others. This first kind is excellent, the second good, and the third kind useless"
About this Quote
Machiavelli isn’t praising brainpower so much as sorting people by political usefulness. The hierarchy flatters the self-sufficient mind first: the person who can size up a situation without borrowing a worldview, who can read motives, incentives, and likely outcomes without needing the story explained. That’s the ideal counselor and, more importantly, the ideal prince - someone who doesn’t outsource judgment.
The second type is a subtler compliment. “Appreciates what others can understand” isn’t mere parroting; it’s the capacity to recognize competence in someone else’s reasoning, to follow an argument and act on it. In a court, this is the reliable operator: not visionary, but coachable, capable of translating another’s insight into execution. Machiavelli, a bureaucrat turned political exile, knew states aren’t run only by geniuses. They’re run by systems of comprehension.
The third category is where his cynicism sharpens. “Understands neither for itself nor through others” is less an insult than a condemnation of incuriosity and vanity: the person who can’t grasp reality and can’t even recognize it when presented plainly. In Machiavelli’s world, that’s not harmless ignorance; it’s a liability that breeds superstition, faction, and self-deception - the raw material of bad decisions dressed up as destiny.
Context matters: writing in the churn of Renaissance Italian politics, Machiavelli treats intelligence as an instrument of survival. The subtext is ruthless meritocracy: if you can’t perceive the world or trust those who can, you don’t just fail an exam. You endanger the state.
The second type is a subtler compliment. “Appreciates what others can understand” isn’t mere parroting; it’s the capacity to recognize competence in someone else’s reasoning, to follow an argument and act on it. In a court, this is the reliable operator: not visionary, but coachable, capable of translating another’s insight into execution. Machiavelli, a bureaucrat turned political exile, knew states aren’t run only by geniuses. They’re run by systems of comprehension.
The third category is where his cynicism sharpens. “Understands neither for itself nor through others” is less an insult than a condemnation of incuriosity and vanity: the person who can’t grasp reality and can’t even recognize it when presented plainly. In Machiavelli’s world, that’s not harmless ignorance; it’s a liability that breeds superstition, faction, and self-deception - the raw material of bad decisions dressed up as destiny.
Context matters: writing in the churn of Renaissance Italian politics, Machiavelli treats intelligence as an instrument of survival. The subtext is ruthless meritocracy: if you can’t perceive the world or trust those who can, you don’t just fail an exam. You endanger the state.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Niccolo
Add to List
