"There aren't just bad people that commit genocide; we are all capable of it. It's our evolutionary history"
About this Quote
Genocide is usually packaged as an alien pathology: monsters do monstrous things, the rest of us watch in horrified innocence. Lovelock detonates that comfort. By insisting "we are all capable of it", he’s not excusing perpetrators; he’s stripping away the moral alibi that makes prevention feel optional. The provocation works because it refuses the flattering story modern societies tell about themselves: that education, affluence, or liberal norms inoculate us against mass cruelty.
Coming from a scientist, the second sentence is the key move. "It's our evolutionary history" drags genocide out of the courtroom and into the lab, reframing it as an extreme expression of familiar human equipment: in-group loyalty, threat perception, status seeking, obedience, contagion of fear. The subtext is grimly pragmatic: if the impulse is latent in ordinary people, then the most dangerous moments are not when a society is full of villains, but when institutions fail and propaganda turns neighbors into risks, rivals, or contaminants.
Lovelock’s broader context matters. As the thinker behind Gaia theory, he spent a career arguing that humans are not separate from nature but embedded in it, governed by the same cold pressures and feedback loops. Here, that worldview becomes a warning: moral progress is real but fragile. Civilization isn’t a guaranteed upward arc; it’s a set of safeguards. Remove them and the species doesn’t revert to barbarism so much as it reveals what it was always capable of.
Coming from a scientist, the second sentence is the key move. "It's our evolutionary history" drags genocide out of the courtroom and into the lab, reframing it as an extreme expression of familiar human equipment: in-group loyalty, threat perception, status seeking, obedience, contagion of fear. The subtext is grimly pragmatic: if the impulse is latent in ordinary people, then the most dangerous moments are not when a society is full of villains, but when institutions fail and propaganda turns neighbors into risks, rivals, or contaminants.
Lovelock’s broader context matters. As the thinker behind Gaia theory, he spent a career arguing that humans are not separate from nature but embedded in it, governed by the same cold pressures and feedback loops. Here, that worldview becomes a warning: moral progress is real but fragile. Civilization isn’t a guaranteed upward arc; it’s a set of safeguards. Remove them and the species doesn’t revert to barbarism so much as it reveals what it was always capable of.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List







