"There can be no liberty without the law"
About this Quote
Liberty sounds like a wild stallion in American myth, but DeMille yanks the reins: no law, no freedom. Coming from a producer who built epics out of commandments, plagues, and spectacle, the line isn’t a civics-teacher platitude so much as a statement of aesthetic and political taste. DeMille’s movies (and the culture they fed) treat order as a prerequisite for grandeur. The frame has to be stable for the drama to land.
The intent is corrective. It pushes back against a populist, frontier-flavored idea of liberty as pure personal license. DeMille is arguing that freedom isn’t the absence of constraint; it’s the presence of a shared system that stops the strong from simply renaming their power “independence.” The subtext is anxious and a little paternal: people left to their own devices will drift toward chaos, and chaos is just another word for someone else’s domination. Law, in this formulation, isn’t the enemy of the individual; it’s the technology that makes individuality survivable.
Context matters: DeMille’s career spans prohibition, the Depression, World War II, and the early Cold War, decades when mass media and mass politics were renegotiating who gets to speak, move, own, and belong. His line flatters a certain American self-image: we’re not ruled by kings, we’re ruled by rules. It’s also a neat piece of rhetorical judo, because it reframes obedience as a form of independence. You can hear the pitchman’s instincts: sell discipline as liberation, and the audience applauds while the leash tightens.
The intent is corrective. It pushes back against a populist, frontier-flavored idea of liberty as pure personal license. DeMille is arguing that freedom isn’t the absence of constraint; it’s the presence of a shared system that stops the strong from simply renaming their power “independence.” The subtext is anxious and a little paternal: people left to their own devices will drift toward chaos, and chaos is just another word for someone else’s domination. Law, in this formulation, isn’t the enemy of the individual; it’s the technology that makes individuality survivable.
Context matters: DeMille’s career spans prohibition, the Depression, World War II, and the early Cold War, decades when mass media and mass politics were renegotiating who gets to speak, move, own, and belong. His line flatters a certain American self-image: we’re not ruled by kings, we’re ruled by rules. It’s also a neat piece of rhetorical judo, because it reframes obedience as a form of independence. You can hear the pitchman’s instincts: sell discipline as liberation, and the audience applauds while the leash tightens.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Cecil
Add to List
