"There is a very well-defined procedure that allows the Vatican to raise issues with a particular theologian about something that does not appear in conformity with the Catholic faith. It is not always easy to make this determination"
About this Quote
A bureaucrat’s lullaby, sung in clerical robes. Danneels leans on the soothing authority of “a very well-defined procedure” to project calm and legitimacy precisely where the ground is unstable: the Vatican policing the boundaries of belief. The sentence performs institutional competence, but its real function is political. “Procedure” is a shield. It tells outsiders that discipline isn’t arbitrary while quietly reminding insiders that Rome always has tools to correct, warn, or silence.
The interesting move is the passive phrasing: issues are “raised,” something “does not appear in conformity.” No one is named, no accusation is owned. That ambiguity is the point. The Church’s doctrinal gatekeeping often depends on maintaining a haze between objective truth and interpretive judgment. By choosing “does not appear,” Danneels signals that orthodoxy is not merely a matter of quoting dogma; it’s a matter of perception, emphasis, and sometimes optics. The line acknowledges, almost against its will, that theology is lived on the edge of language, where a small shift in framing can look like heresy or like development.
Then comes the second sentence, the tell: “It is not always easy to make this determination.” That concession reads as pastoral modesty, but it also exposes the tension between a centralized magisterium and a global intellectual church. Danneels, a cardinal with firsthand experience of Rome’s disciplinary machinery, is hinting that the system’s authority rests not just on truth claims but on contested judgment calls. It’s a quiet admission that the Church’s internal debates are less courtroom certainty than curial triage.
The interesting move is the passive phrasing: issues are “raised,” something “does not appear in conformity.” No one is named, no accusation is owned. That ambiguity is the point. The Church’s doctrinal gatekeeping often depends on maintaining a haze between objective truth and interpretive judgment. By choosing “does not appear,” Danneels signals that orthodoxy is not merely a matter of quoting dogma; it’s a matter of perception, emphasis, and sometimes optics. The line acknowledges, almost against its will, that theology is lived on the edge of language, where a small shift in framing can look like heresy or like development.
Then comes the second sentence, the tell: “It is not always easy to make this determination.” That concession reads as pastoral modesty, but it also exposes the tension between a centralized magisterium and a global intellectual church. Danneels, a cardinal with firsthand experience of Rome’s disciplinary machinery, is hinting that the system’s authority rests not just on truth claims but on contested judgment calls. It’s a quiet admission that the Church’s internal debates are less courtroom certainty than curial triage.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Godfried
Add to List
