"There is always a "but" in this imperfect world"
About this Quote
Even at her most compressed, Anne Bronte writes like someone who has audited hope and found the fine print. "There is always a 'but' in this imperfect world" is a small sentence with a stiff spine: it refuses the clean, inspirational arc. The quoted "but" matters. Bronte isn’t just naming disappointment; she’s dramatizing it as an intrusion, a spoken interruption that turns certainty into negotiation. The punctuation gives the word a sneer. You can hear the moment a promise is revised, a romance reinterpreted, a moral lesson complicated by what actually happens to women with limited choices.
The intent is less nihilism than clear-eyed resistance to sentimental narratives. Bronte, often read as the most "realist" of the Bronte sisters, is interested in the everyday mechanics of power: respectable people who do harm, institutions that claim virtue while enabling vice, affection that comes attached to conditions. The "but" is the hinge between public ideals and private consequences. It’s the clause that lets society keep its self-image intact: I believe in goodness, but... I respect you, but... I would help, but...
Contextually, it sits comfortably beside the moral grit of Agnes Grey and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, where innocence meets predation and reform meets social inertia. The line works because it’s plainspoken and fatalistic without being theatrical. It doesn’t beg for sympathy; it warns you to listen for the qualifying clause, because that’s where the truth usually hides.
The intent is less nihilism than clear-eyed resistance to sentimental narratives. Bronte, often read as the most "realist" of the Bronte sisters, is interested in the everyday mechanics of power: respectable people who do harm, institutions that claim virtue while enabling vice, affection that comes attached to conditions. The "but" is the hinge between public ideals and private consequences. It’s the clause that lets society keep its self-image intact: I believe in goodness, but... I respect you, but... I would help, but...
Contextually, it sits comfortably beside the moral grit of Agnes Grey and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, where innocence meets predation and reform meets social inertia. The line works because it’s plainspoken and fatalistic without being theatrical. It doesn’t beg for sympathy; it warns you to listen for the qualifying clause, because that’s where the truth usually hides.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: The Tenant of Wildfell Hall (Anne Bronte, 1848)
Evidence: Volume 2, Chapter 3 (Helen's diary entry dated “22nd.”); sometimes labeled Chapter XXII (continued) in online editions. The line appears in Anne Brontë’s novel as part of Helen’s diary: “...but, there is always a but in this imperfect world, ...”. This is a primary-text location; later quote site... Other candidates (1) Anne Brontë (Anne Bronte) compilation96.7% its of friendship rachel to helen there is always a but in this imperfect world |
| Featured | This quote was our Quote of the Day on February 2, 2025 |
More Quotes by Anne
Add to List








