"There is always a need for intoxication: China has opium, Islam has hashish, the West has woman"
About this Quote
Malraux’s line lands like a smug aphorism and then curdles in your mouth, which is exactly the point. It’s a colonial-era provocation disguised as anthropology: every civilization, he implies, requires an anesthetic, and the West’s preferred drug is not a substance but a person. The sting comes from the grammatical sleight of hand. Opium and hashish are objects; “woman” is treated as the same kind of consumable, a civilizational narcotic administered to men. It’s not simply misogyny; it’s misogyny dressed up as comparative cultural insight, which gives it a cooler, more corrosive authority.
The subtext is a three-way hierarchy. China and Islam are reduced to stereotypes of exotic vice, while “the West” gets a vice that flatters its self-image: not stupor but desire, romance, the sophisticated intoxication of erotic pursuit. Yet the compliment is double-edged. If women function as the West’s opiate, then Western modernity runs on distraction too, just with better lighting and a moral alibi. “Need” is the key word: he’s arguing that rational civilization is a veneer, and that all societies quietly engineer escapes from the burden of consciousness.
Context matters. Malraux wrote in a century of imperial afterglow, mass politics, and disillusioned intellectuals trying to diagnose what people worship when old certainties collapse. This sentence belongs to that tradition of European cultural pessimism: witty, sweeping, and willing to sacrifice whole populations to make the epigram click. It works because it’s concise, nasty, and revealing, even as it exposes the author’s own blind spots.
The subtext is a three-way hierarchy. China and Islam are reduced to stereotypes of exotic vice, while “the West” gets a vice that flatters its self-image: not stupor but desire, romance, the sophisticated intoxication of erotic pursuit. Yet the compliment is double-edged. If women function as the West’s opiate, then Western modernity runs on distraction too, just with better lighting and a moral alibi. “Need” is the key word: he’s arguing that rational civilization is a veneer, and that all societies quietly engineer escapes from the burden of consciousness.
Context matters. Malraux wrote in a century of imperial afterglow, mass politics, and disillusioned intellectuals trying to diagnose what people worship when old certainties collapse. This sentence belongs to that tradition of European cultural pessimism: witty, sweeping, and willing to sacrifice whole populations to make the epigram click. It works because it’s concise, nasty, and revealing, even as it exposes the author’s own blind spots.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Andre
Add to List
