"There is no excuse for this administration shielding information about Iraq and the fact that we have great difficulties there from the American people"
About this Quote
The line lands like a civics lesson delivered with a prosecutor's cadence: not just that Iraq is going badly, but that the greater offense is the attempted management of public reality. Inslee frames the situation as a double crisis - a strategic failure overseas and a democratic failure at home. The key phrase is "no excuse", a moral absolute that preempts the usual Washington defenses (classification, operational security, complicated timelines). He's not arguing policy at first; he's indicting process.
"Shielding information" is a careful verb choice. It implies paternalism rather than mere omission: the administration isn't simply wrong, it's treating citizens like hazards to be contained. Then he sharpens the blade with "the fact that we have great difficulties there". "Fact" dares opponents to call him a partisan. It also smuggles in a demand for shared reality at a moment when Iraq discourse was saturated with euphemism - "turning corners", "mission accomplished", optimistic metrics that seemed designed for cable hits, not accountability.
The subtext is political but not merely tactical. Inslee is positioning Democrats as guardians of transparency after the early-2000s credibility collapse over weapons of mass destruction and the shifting rationales for war. "From the American people" widens the jury beyond Congress or the press; it implies that the electorate itself has been wronged, and that consent for war requires truthful disclosure, especially when costs are escalating. It's an argument about legitimacy: if the public is kept in the dark, the war effort isn't just harder - it's less defensible.
"Shielding information" is a careful verb choice. It implies paternalism rather than mere omission: the administration isn't simply wrong, it's treating citizens like hazards to be contained. Then he sharpens the blade with "the fact that we have great difficulties there". "Fact" dares opponents to call him a partisan. It also smuggles in a demand for shared reality at a moment when Iraq discourse was saturated with euphemism - "turning corners", "mission accomplished", optimistic metrics that seemed designed for cable hits, not accountability.
The subtext is political but not merely tactical. Inslee is positioning Democrats as guardians of transparency after the early-2000s credibility collapse over weapons of mass destruction and the shifting rationales for war. "From the American people" widens the jury beyond Congress or the press; it implies that the electorate itself has been wronged, and that consent for war requires truthful disclosure, especially when costs are escalating. It's an argument about legitimacy: if the public is kept in the dark, the war effort isn't just harder - it's less defensible.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Jay
Add to List




