"There is no justice among men"
About this Quote
A tsar admitting the system is rigged is less a confession than a diagnosis delivered from the penthouse. “There is no justice among men” reads like fatalism, but from Nicholas II it also functions as a quiet alibi: if justice is impossible, then responsibility is optional. The phrasing is sweeping, almost biblical, the kind of line that turns political failure into metaphysical weather. No villains, no remedies, just a fallen world.
That move matters because Nicholas ruled at a moment when “justice” wasn’t an abstract virtue but a live demand: peasants burdened by land hunger, industrial workers testing the edges of legality, revolutionaries making the moral case that autocracy was organized theft. After 1905, after Bloody Sunday, after the Duma experiment that never became real sovereignty, the word “justice” had a paper trail of petitions, strikes, and bullets. For a monarch whose legitimacy rested on divine right, conceding that human institutions can’t deliver justice is also a way to reassert the only justice that counts: God’s, mediated by the crown.
The subtext is almost claustrophobic: Nicholas often comes across in the historical record as personally devout, emotionally inward, and politically outmatched. This sentence compresses that temperament into a worldview where tragedy is preordained and reform is suspect. It’s also a tell of how autocracy collapses: not only through force and famine, but through leaders who treat moral claims as noise. When a ruler shrugs at justice, the street stops asking politely.
That move matters because Nicholas ruled at a moment when “justice” wasn’t an abstract virtue but a live demand: peasants burdened by land hunger, industrial workers testing the edges of legality, revolutionaries making the moral case that autocracy was organized theft. After 1905, after Bloody Sunday, after the Duma experiment that never became real sovereignty, the word “justice” had a paper trail of petitions, strikes, and bullets. For a monarch whose legitimacy rested on divine right, conceding that human institutions can’t deliver justice is also a way to reassert the only justice that counts: God’s, mediated by the crown.
The subtext is almost claustrophobic: Nicholas often comes across in the historical record as personally devout, emotionally inward, and politically outmatched. This sentence compresses that temperament into a worldview where tragedy is preordained and reform is suspect. It’s also a tell of how autocracy collapses: not only through force and famine, but through leaders who treat moral claims as noise. When a ruler shrugs at justice, the street stops asking politely.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Rejected source: Pisma imperatritsy Aleksandry Fedorovny k imperatoru Niko... (Alexandra, Empress, consort of Nichol..., 1922)IA: pismaimperatrits01alex
Evidence: at i would do once you are not there she is glad to get out of the house its no Other candidates (2) Tsar Nicholas II (Hourly History, 2017) compilation95.0% ... There is no justice among men.” —Tsar Nicholas II One of the great ironies of Alexander II's assassination by rad... Greatness (Nicholas II) compilation50.0% e vastly increase the range of our understanding and sympathy there is no middle |
More Quotes by Nicholas
Add to List









