"There is no longer any such thing as fiction or nonfiction; there's only narrative"
About this Quote
Doctorow’s line is a dare aimed at the literary border patrol. He’s not claiming that facts don’t exist; he’s arguing that the minute facts are arranged, they become a story with a point of view, a camera angle, a rhythm of revelations. “Fiction” and “nonfiction” sound like clean categories, but “narrative” is the messy reality: a set of choices about what to include, what to omit, where to begin, and whose consciousness gets the microphone.
The intent is partly defensive and partly aggressive. Doctorow, famous for historical novels like Ragtime and The Book of Daniel, spent a career being asked to justify his liberties with the record. This sentence reframes the charge. If the historian and the novelist are both shaping raw material into meaning, then the moral question isn’t “Did you invent?” but “What kind of truth are you pursuing, and at what cost?” It’s an aesthetic argument with ethical teeth: narrative is power, because it can naturalize an interpretation until it feels like reality.
The subtext has only gotten sharper in an era of prestige “true story” TV, memoir-as-brand, and news ecosystems built for bingeable arcs. We don’t consume information; we consume plotted experience. Doctorow’s cynicism is quiet but pointed: once everything is narrative, credibility is less about verification than about voice, coherence, and emotional payoff. The warning is embedded in the elegance. If all roads lead to narrative, then the fight shifts from genre labels to the harder work of resisting seductive storytelling when it flatters our priors.
The intent is partly defensive and partly aggressive. Doctorow, famous for historical novels like Ragtime and The Book of Daniel, spent a career being asked to justify his liberties with the record. This sentence reframes the charge. If the historian and the novelist are both shaping raw material into meaning, then the moral question isn’t “Did you invent?” but “What kind of truth are you pursuing, and at what cost?” It’s an aesthetic argument with ethical teeth: narrative is power, because it can naturalize an interpretation until it feels like reality.
The subtext has only gotten sharper in an era of prestige “true story” TV, memoir-as-brand, and news ecosystems built for bingeable arcs. We don’t consume information; we consume plotted experience. Doctorow’s cynicism is quiet but pointed: once everything is narrative, credibility is less about verification than about voice, coherence, and emotional payoff. The warning is embedded in the elegance. If all roads lead to narrative, then the fight shifts from genre labels to the harder work of resisting seductive storytelling when it flatters our priors.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by L. Doctorow
Add to List
