"There is no scorn more profound, or on the whole more justifiable, than that of the men who make for the men who explain. Exposition, criticism, appreciation, is work for second-rate minds"
About this Quote
Hardy is throwing a cold, bright light on a hierarchy most creative fields pretend they do not have: the maker at the top, the interpreter beneath. The line is meant to sting. "Scorn" is not accidental; it frames explanation as parasitic, a kind of intellectual freeloading that feeds on the primary act of creation. Coming from a mathematician who prized "pure" work and distrusted utility, the jab lands as cultural boundary-policing: real thought is invention, not narration.
The subtext is anxiety as much as arrogance. Pure mathematics lives in a medium that resists translation. To explain is to simplify; to simplify is to risk falsifying the experience of mathematical insight. Hardy is defending the privacy of that experience, and by extension, the prestige of those who can access it without a guide. His claim that exposition and criticism are "work for second-rate minds" is less an empirical judgment than a protective myth: it keeps the mystique intact, and it warns young mathematicians away from careers that look like accommodation.
Context matters: Hardy wrote in a Britain where "applied" work was increasingly valorized, especially around wartime, and where he explicitly championed mathematics as a kind of art. In that world, the explainer is a broker between elite culture and the crowd, and brokers are always suspect. The irony is that Hardy's own rhetorical brilliance - his aphoristic bite, his carefully staged disdain - is itself a form of exposition. Even his scorn needs an audience.
The subtext is anxiety as much as arrogance. Pure mathematics lives in a medium that resists translation. To explain is to simplify; to simplify is to risk falsifying the experience of mathematical insight. Hardy is defending the privacy of that experience, and by extension, the prestige of those who can access it without a guide. His claim that exposition and criticism are "work for second-rate minds" is less an empirical judgment than a protective myth: it keeps the mystique intact, and it warns young mathematicians away from careers that look like accommodation.
Context matters: Hardy wrote in a Britain where "applied" work was increasingly valorized, especially around wartime, and where he explicitly championed mathematics as a kind of art. In that world, the explainer is a broker between elite culture and the crowd, and brokers are always suspect. The irony is that Hardy's own rhetorical brilliance - his aphoristic bite, his carefully staged disdain - is itself a form of exposition. Even his scorn needs an audience.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by H. Hardy
Add to List







