"There is no single development, in either technology or management technique, which by itself promises even one order-of-magnitude improvement within a decade in productivity, in reliability, in simplicity"
About this Quote
Brooks is swinging a hammer at Silicon Valley's favorite fairy tale: the “one weird trick” that will make messy work clean. Written with the cool patience of someone who built real systems and watched them break in real time, the line refuses the romance of exponential progress. The phrasing is lawyerly but lethal: “no single development,” “by itself,” “even one order-of-magnitude,” “within a decade.” Each clause tightens the noose around hype.
The intent is partly predictive, partly moral. Brooks isn’t denying improvement; he’s denying salvation. In software (his home turf), the hard problems aren’t just slow CPUs or clumsy workflows. They’re complexity, coordination, and the brutal fact that every new feature is another promise you have to keep forever. Management fads and technical breakthroughs can shift the cost curve, but they don’t repeal the underlying physics of large systems: bugs emerge from interaction, not ignorance; schedules slip because humans misunderstand each other as much as machines.
Subtext: stop waiting for the miracle and start doing the unglamorous work. Brooks is implicitly arguing for plural, incremental gains - better tools, better practices, better communication - none of which gets to wear the cape alone. The quote lands because it punctures optimism without lapsing into doom. It’s a mature kind of skepticism: the kind that comes from seeing “the next big thing” arrive, disappoint, and then quietly become just another part of the stack.
Context matters: Brooks wrote in an era when computing power and new languages tempted people to believe productivity could jump like hardware did. He’s reminding us that the bottleneck is often us.
The intent is partly predictive, partly moral. Brooks isn’t denying improvement; he’s denying salvation. In software (his home turf), the hard problems aren’t just slow CPUs or clumsy workflows. They’re complexity, coordination, and the brutal fact that every new feature is another promise you have to keep forever. Management fads and technical breakthroughs can shift the cost curve, but they don’t repeal the underlying physics of large systems: bugs emerge from interaction, not ignorance; schedules slip because humans misunderstand each other as much as machines.
Subtext: stop waiting for the miracle and start doing the unglamorous work. Brooks is implicitly arguing for plural, incremental gains - better tools, better practices, better communication - none of which gets to wear the cape alone. The quote lands because it punctures optimism without lapsing into doom. It’s a mature kind of skepticism: the kind that comes from seeing “the next big thing” arrive, disappoint, and then quietly become just another part of the stack.
Context matters: Brooks wrote in an era when computing power and new languages tempted people to believe productivity could jump like hardware did. He’s reminding us that the bottleneck is often us.
Quote Details
| Topic | Technology |
|---|
More Quotes by Frederick
Add to List
