"There is no such thing as a fixed policy, because policy like all organic entities is always in the making"
About this Quote
Fixed policy is a comforting fantasy: the idea that good governance can be sealed in wax and stored on a shelf. Richard Cecil, an Anglican clergyman writing in an age of revolutions, punctures that fantasy by likening policy to an "organic" entity: alive, contingent, and never finished. The line is doing two things at once. It sounds almost managerial, but it smuggles in a moral warning.
Cecil's intent is to humble certainty. Late-18th-century Britain was watching old orders crack under the pressure of industrial change, colonial aftershocks, and the French Revolution's ideological shockwaves. In that climate, a "fixed policy" looks less like principle and more like stubbornness dressed up as virtue. Calling policy organic is also a rhetorical trapdoor: if policy is alive, then it must respond to environment, adapt to new information, and sometimes shed old skin. Refusing to evolve becomes not strength but sickness.
The subtext, especially coming from a clergyman, is about human limitation. Cecil isn't arguing for spineless opportunism; he's arguing against the idolatry of systems. Institutions and leaders often treat policy as doctrine because doctrine confers authority. Cecil flips that: authority should come from ongoing discernment, not from pretending yesterday's answers are eternally adequate.
The phrasing "always in the making" lands like a rebuke to ideological purity. It suggests politics is closer to stewardship than conquest: you manage living complexity, you don't impose a final draft. In a moment when modern politics still fetishizes "consistency" as character, Cecil reads as bracingly unsentimental - and quietly radical.
Cecil's intent is to humble certainty. Late-18th-century Britain was watching old orders crack under the pressure of industrial change, colonial aftershocks, and the French Revolution's ideological shockwaves. In that climate, a "fixed policy" looks less like principle and more like stubbornness dressed up as virtue. Calling policy organic is also a rhetorical trapdoor: if policy is alive, then it must respond to environment, adapt to new information, and sometimes shed old skin. Refusing to evolve becomes not strength but sickness.
The subtext, especially coming from a clergyman, is about human limitation. Cecil isn't arguing for spineless opportunism; he's arguing against the idolatry of systems. Institutions and leaders often treat policy as doctrine because doctrine confers authority. Cecil flips that: authority should come from ongoing discernment, not from pretending yesterday's answers are eternally adequate.
The phrasing "always in the making" lands like a rebuke to ideological purity. It suggests politics is closer to stewardship than conquest: you manage living complexity, you don't impose a final draft. In a moment when modern politics still fetishizes "consistency" as character, Cecil reads as bracingly unsentimental - and quietly radical.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List



