"There is no way that you can ever really repeat something. I have this great belief that the magic of the moment can never be recaptured"
About this Quote
Brian May’s line lands like a gentle rebuke to the modern fantasy that everything great can be rerun on demand. Coming from a musician whose band has spent decades navigating reissues, remasters, tribute tours, and the expectation that Queen can continually summon Live Aid-level electricity, it’s not nostalgia talking. It’s craft realism.
The intent is protective: defend the fleeting, unrepeatable chemistry that happens when a performance isn’t yet a product. May is pushing back against the idea that if you just get the same players, the same setlist, the same gear, you can manufacture the same transcendence. You can reconstruct the notes, even the lighting cues. You can’t reconstruct the exact psychological weather: the audience’s mood, the band’s nerves, the cultural temperature outside the venue, the tiny accidents that turn a good night into a myth.
The subtext is also a critique of how we consume music now. Streaming culture trains us to treat art as infinitely rewindable, flattening time into a playlist. May insists that “magic” is partly scarcity: not in the artificial, ticket-scalper sense, but in the human sense that bodies age, contexts shift, grief and joy accumulate, and the same song means something different every time you return to it.
He’s not dismissing rehearsal or legacy. He’s arguing that the most valuable part of performance is precisely what can’t be archived: the moment when everyone in the room is briefly, irreversibly, only there.
The intent is protective: defend the fleeting, unrepeatable chemistry that happens when a performance isn’t yet a product. May is pushing back against the idea that if you just get the same players, the same setlist, the same gear, you can manufacture the same transcendence. You can reconstruct the notes, even the lighting cues. You can’t reconstruct the exact psychological weather: the audience’s mood, the band’s nerves, the cultural temperature outside the venue, the tiny accidents that turn a good night into a myth.
The subtext is also a critique of how we consume music now. Streaming culture trains us to treat art as infinitely rewindable, flattening time into a playlist. May insists that “magic” is partly scarcity: not in the artificial, ticket-scalper sense, but in the human sense that bodies age, contexts shift, grief and joy accumulate, and the same song means something different every time you return to it.
He’s not dismissing rehearsal or legacy. He’s arguing that the most valuable part of performance is precisely what can’t be archived: the moment when everyone in the room is briefly, irreversibly, only there.
Quote Details
| Topic | Live in the Moment |
|---|
More Quotes by Brian
Add to List
