"There is no winning or losing, but rather the value is in the experience of imagining yourself as a character in whatever genre you're involved in, whether it's a fantasy game, the Wild West, secret agenst or whatever else. You get to sort of vicariously experience those things"
About this Quote
Strip away the dice and the rulebooks and Gygax is making a quietly radical claim: the point of play isn’t conquest, it’s inhabitation. “No winning or losing” reads like a rebuttal to the then-dominant idea of games as scoreboards and finish lines. In early tabletop culture, where war games and competitive hobbies set the tone, Dungeons & Dragons smuggled in a different value system: narrative as reward, identity as gameplay.
The phrasing matters. “Imagining yourself as a character” puts the self on the operating table. You’re not just moving a token; you’re testing a version of you under pressure, in costume. The list of genres - fantasy, Wild West, secret agent - is a sales pitch, but it’s also a thesis about modular desire. D&D isn’t one story; it’s a machine for trying on stories, a toolkit for fantasies that other media mostly hand you prepackaged. The subtext is democratic: you don’t need Hollywood budgets or real-world permission to enter these worlds. You need friends, time, and a shared willingness to pretend.
“Vicariously” does double duty. It acknowledges escapism without apology, framing it as experiential rather than evasive. In the late 20th-century moral panics around role-playing games, that’s defensive but also defiant: yes, you’re elsewhere; that’s the feature. Gygax is arguing for play as a legitimate way to explore risk, heroism, and choice - not as a substitute for life, but as a rehearsal space where meaning is made collaboratively, not tallied.
The phrasing matters. “Imagining yourself as a character” puts the self on the operating table. You’re not just moving a token; you’re testing a version of you under pressure, in costume. The list of genres - fantasy, Wild West, secret agent - is a sales pitch, but it’s also a thesis about modular desire. D&D isn’t one story; it’s a machine for trying on stories, a toolkit for fantasies that other media mostly hand you prepackaged. The subtext is democratic: you don’t need Hollywood budgets or real-world permission to enter these worlds. You need friends, time, and a shared willingness to pretend.
“Vicariously” does double duty. It acknowledges escapism without apology, framing it as experiential rather than evasive. In the late 20th-century moral panics around role-playing games, that’s defensive but also defiant: yes, you’re elsewhere; that’s the feature. Gygax is arguing for play as a legitimate way to explore risk, heroism, and choice - not as a substitute for life, but as a rehearsal space where meaning is made collaboratively, not tallied.
Quote Details
| Topic | Adventure |
|---|
More Quotes by Gary
Add to List
