"There is nothing deep down inside us except what we have put there ourselves"
About this Quote
Rorty’s line lands like a small act of vandalism against the modern obsession with “authenticity.” It’s a refusal of the comforting idea that somewhere beneath our habits and social masks sits a pure, prepackaged self waiting to be excavated. The barb is that the excavation metaphor is backwards: there’s no buried treasure, just the sediment of what you’ve practiced, believed, read, repeated, and been rewarded for.
The intent is anti-essentialist and quietly therapeutic. Rorty, the pragmatist who distrusted philosophical “foundations,” is stripping away the notion that identity rests on inner bedrock - a true nature, a fixed soul, a hardwired moral compass. What’s left is agency, but not the heroic kind. You “put” things inside yourself through language and community: the vocabularies you inherit, the stories you tell about pain, success, love, shame. The subtext is that selfhood is less discovery than composition, closer to editing than to revelation.
Context matters: Rorty is pushing back against both religious metaphysics and the secularized version of it in theory-heavy philosophy - the hope that if we dig deep enough we’ll find certainty. He replaces that with contingency and self-creation, which is bracing and, for some, bleak. Yet the line also smuggles in a moral challenge: if there’s nothing “deep down” to blame or credit, you can’t outsource responsibility to destiny or temperament. You become the result of your commitments - and you can revise them, not by finding your “real self,” but by writing a better one.
The intent is anti-essentialist and quietly therapeutic. Rorty, the pragmatist who distrusted philosophical “foundations,” is stripping away the notion that identity rests on inner bedrock - a true nature, a fixed soul, a hardwired moral compass. What’s left is agency, but not the heroic kind. You “put” things inside yourself through language and community: the vocabularies you inherit, the stories you tell about pain, success, love, shame. The subtext is that selfhood is less discovery than composition, closer to editing than to revelation.
Context matters: Rorty is pushing back against both religious metaphysics and the secularized version of it in theory-heavy philosophy - the hope that if we dig deep enough we’ll find certainty. He replaces that with contingency and self-creation, which is bracing and, for some, bleak. Yet the line also smuggles in a moral challenge: if there’s nothing “deep down” to blame or credit, you can’t outsource responsibility to destiny or temperament. You become the result of your commitments - and you can revise them, not by finding your “real self,” but by writing a better one.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List









