"There is nothing more boring than doing singing exercises"
About this Quote
Boredom is a strange flex coming from P. J. Harvey, an artist whose whole career is built on making discomfort sound electric. When she says, "There is nothing more boring than doing singing exercises", she is not denying craft; she is drawing a line between technique as maintenance and music as meaning. Vocal drills are the gym treadmill of artistry: undeniably useful, often soul-numbing, and easy to confuse with the thing you actually came for.
Harvey's intent reads like a small act of rebellion against a certain kind of institutional polish. Singing exercises imply obedience to a system: correct breathing, correct vowels, correct tone. Her work has long prized character over correctness, the cracked edge of a voice that sounds like a person living inside it. The subtext is that discipline without imagination is dead air. You can train the instrument and still miss the point if you are not chasing an idea, a mood, a story, a threat.
Context matters, too. Harvey emerged in a rock landscape where women were routinely pressured to sound "pretty" or "proper" to be legible to gatekeepers. Calling exercises boring is a way of shrugging off that demand and re-centering performance as expression rather than compliance. It's also a musician talking plainly about the unglamorous labor behind the myth. The line works because it's funny, a little bratty, and quietly profound: art isn't improved by suffering through the correct routines; it's improved by wanting to say something badly enough that the voice, trained or not, has to follow.
Harvey's intent reads like a small act of rebellion against a certain kind of institutional polish. Singing exercises imply obedience to a system: correct breathing, correct vowels, correct tone. Her work has long prized character over correctness, the cracked edge of a voice that sounds like a person living inside it. The subtext is that discipline without imagination is dead air. You can train the instrument and still miss the point if you are not chasing an idea, a mood, a story, a threat.
Context matters, too. Harvey emerged in a rock landscape where women were routinely pressured to sound "pretty" or "proper" to be legible to gatekeepers. Calling exercises boring is a way of shrugging off that demand and re-centering performance as expression rather than compliance. It's also a musician talking plainly about the unglamorous labor behind the myth. The line works because it's funny, a little bratty, and quietly profound: art isn't improved by suffering through the correct routines; it's improved by wanting to say something badly enough that the voice, trained or not, has to follow.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by J. Harvey
Add to List


