"There is science, logic, reason; there is thought verified by experience. And then there is California"
About this Quote
A neat little hatchet job disguised as a travel postcard, Abbey's line draws its laugh from a ruthless binary: on one side, the dignified furniture of modernity ("science, logic, reason"), stacked in ascending order like a courtroom brief; on the other, "California", dropped as a punchline so broad it becomes a verdict. The humor is in the syntactic feint. He pretends to praise rationality, then yanks the floor away with a single proper noun, implying the state exists outside the rules that supposedly govern everything else.
Abbey's specific intent isn't to debate Californians point by point; it's to brand California as a cultural exception, the place where ideology, spectacle, and wishful thinking routinely outrun material limits. Coming from a writer whose environmental politics were both fierce and contrarian, the jab also reads as a Western rivalry: desert realist versus coastal dream factory. "Thought verified by experience" is Abbey's home terrain, the austere, field-tested knowledge of wilderness and work. California becomes shorthand for the opposite: a landscape engineered to deny its own ecology (water piped, hillside homes, perpetual reinvention), and a social imagination built on novelty, wellness fads, and self-mythology.
The subtext is less "California is dumb" than "California is incurably performative". Abbey is irritated by a culture that can sell transcendence while sidestepping consequences. The line works because it treats a state like a philosophical category, making regional resentment feel like a law of nature, and letting the reader enjoy the sting without needing the footnotes.
Abbey's specific intent isn't to debate Californians point by point; it's to brand California as a cultural exception, the place where ideology, spectacle, and wishful thinking routinely outrun material limits. Coming from a writer whose environmental politics were both fierce and contrarian, the jab also reads as a Western rivalry: desert realist versus coastal dream factory. "Thought verified by experience" is Abbey's home terrain, the austere, field-tested knowledge of wilderness and work. California becomes shorthand for the opposite: a landscape engineered to deny its own ecology (water piped, hillside homes, perpetual reinvention), and a social imagination built on novelty, wellness fads, and self-mythology.
The subtext is less "California is dumb" than "California is incurably performative". Abbey is irritated by a culture that can sell transcendence while sidestepping consequences. The line works because it treats a state like a philosophical category, making regional resentment feel like a law of nature, and letting the reader enjoy the sting without needing the footnotes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List






