"There is zero debate about whether the world is getting warmer. That is a fact, a measured fact. There is some debate, although not much anymore, about what's causing the world to get warmer. And the consensus, by far is that it's us"
About this Quote
Barnes frames climate change like a courtroom case where the jury has already come back, and the only thing left is to stop grandstanding and read the evidence into the record. The first move is absolute: "zero debate". It's not just confidence; it's a preemptive strike against the cultural habit of treating every issue as a two-sided talk show segment. By repeating "fact" and tightening it with "a measured fact", he leans on instrumentation, not ideology. Thermometers don't have donors.
Then he concedes a sliver of uncertainty about causation, but he does it strategically: "some debate, although not much anymore". That's a rhetorical quarantine. Barnes acknowledges the posture of skepticism without granting it real oxygen, signaling that the argument has shifted from science to delay tactics. The careful pivot matters: he isn't saying science is closed because authority declared it so; he's saying the remaining dispute has become culturally performative.
The final line lands with conversational bluntness: "it's us". No euphemisms, no passive voice, no "anthropogenic emissions" to let the listener off the hook. Barnes is a playwright, and you can hear the stagecraft: he sets up a three-beat rhythm (warming, cause, responsibility) and ends on the only beat that demands consequence. The subtext is moral, not technical: if the warming is measured and the cause is us, then denial isn't an opinion, it's an alibi. In the era when "debate" was being manufactured as a product, Barnes writes a line that tries to cancel the subscription.
Then he concedes a sliver of uncertainty about causation, but he does it strategically: "some debate, although not much anymore". That's a rhetorical quarantine. Barnes acknowledges the posture of skepticism without granting it real oxygen, signaling that the argument has shifted from science to delay tactics. The careful pivot matters: he isn't saying science is closed because authority declared it so; he's saying the remaining dispute has become culturally performative.
The final line lands with conversational bluntness: "it's us". No euphemisms, no passive voice, no "anthropogenic emissions" to let the listener off the hook. Barnes is a playwright, and you can hear the stagecraft: he sets up a three-beat rhythm (warming, cause, responsibility) and ends on the only beat that demands consequence. The subtext is moral, not technical: if the warming is measured and the cause is us, then denial isn't an opinion, it's an alibi. In the era when "debate" was being manufactured as a product, Barnes writes a line that tries to cancel the subscription.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Peter
Add to List
