"There may be a hundred thousand men in an army, who are all equally free; but they only are naturally most fit to be commanders or leaders, who most excel in the virtues required for the right performance of those offices"
About this Quote
Freedom, for Algernon Sidney, is not a raffle ticket that randomly assigns authority. It is the baseline condition from which legitimacy must be earned. In a single stroke, he separates equality of political standing from equality of political function: you can have “a hundred thousand” free men and still accept hierarchy, so long as that hierarchy answers to merit rather than birth, force, or divine paperwork.
That tension is the point. Sidney was writing in the long English aftershock of civil war, regicide, and Restoration, when “liberty” and “order” were rival brands, each claiming moral purity while angling for power. His rhetoric offers a third path: an army of equals that nonetheless selects commanders because some people “excel” in the virtues needed to lead. He’s smuggling republican discipline into a world addicted to inherited rank. Leadership becomes a job with qualifications, not a metaphysical status.
The subtext is a warning aimed upward. If rulers insist they are leaders by nature, Sidney counters that nature’s test is not bloodline but performance. “Virtues required” sounds pious, but it’s a political weapon: it invites judgment, comparison, and, ultimately, replacement. In Sidney’s hands, merit is not a soothing technocratic ideal; it’s a moral audit of authority.
The choice of the army matters, too. Armies embody coercion, yet he imagines even the coercive institution as composed of free agents. It’s an argument that power must be accountable precisely where it’s most dangerous: at the point where obedience is demanded.
That tension is the point. Sidney was writing in the long English aftershock of civil war, regicide, and Restoration, when “liberty” and “order” were rival brands, each claiming moral purity while angling for power. His rhetoric offers a third path: an army of equals that nonetheless selects commanders because some people “excel” in the virtues needed to lead. He’s smuggling republican discipline into a world addicted to inherited rank. Leadership becomes a job with qualifications, not a metaphysical status.
The subtext is a warning aimed upward. If rulers insist they are leaders by nature, Sidney counters that nature’s test is not bloodline but performance. “Virtues required” sounds pious, but it’s a political weapon: it invites judgment, comparison, and, ultimately, replacement. In Sidney’s hands, merit is not a soothing technocratic ideal; it’s a moral audit of authority.
The choice of the army matters, too. Armies embody coercion, yet he imagines even the coercive institution as composed of free agents. It’s an argument that power must be accountable precisely where it’s most dangerous: at the point where obedience is demanded.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|---|
| Source | Algernon Sidney, Discourses Concerning Government (posthumous, 1698). |
More Quotes by Algernon
Add to List
