"There must be possible a fiction which, leaving sociology and case histories to the scientists, can arrive at the truth about the human condition, here and now, with all the bright magic of the fairy tale"
About this Quote
Ellison is drawing a hard line against the era’s favorite alibi: that charts, studies, and “case histories” can stand in for lived reality. Writing in mid-century America, when Black life was routinely translated into data points for white institutions (the sociological report, the psychiatric file, the “problem” novel), he insists fiction has a different jurisdiction. It doesn’t compete with science on evidence; it competes on truth. The sly move is the phrase “here and now.” Ellison isn’t talking about abstract Human Nature. He’s talking about the urgent, contemporary moment - a society obsessed with categorizing people while failing to see them.
The subtext is also a critique of literary realism when it becomes merely documentary. Ellison wants a fiction that can contain social fact without being trapped by it, a story that refuses to reduce characters to symptoms of a system. “Bright magic of the fairy tale” isn’t escapism; it’s a technology for revelation. Fairy tales compress experience into archetype, exaggeration, and symbolic clarity. They make the invisible visible. For Ellison, that’s precisely what a racially stratified society steals: visibility, complexity, interiority. Magic becomes a counter-method to a culture that claims objectivity while practicing erasure.
The intent, then, is a defense of imaginative freedom as moral accuracy. Fiction can tell the truth about the human condition because it can stage contradictions - dignity and degradation, hope and farce - without tidying them into a conclusion. Ellison argues that the only way to meet “here and now” is with art bold enough to be strange.
The subtext is also a critique of literary realism when it becomes merely documentary. Ellison wants a fiction that can contain social fact without being trapped by it, a story that refuses to reduce characters to symptoms of a system. “Bright magic of the fairy tale” isn’t escapism; it’s a technology for revelation. Fairy tales compress experience into archetype, exaggeration, and symbolic clarity. They make the invisible visible. For Ellison, that’s precisely what a racially stratified society steals: visibility, complexity, interiority. Magic becomes a counter-method to a culture that claims objectivity while practicing erasure.
The intent, then, is a defense of imaginative freedom as moral accuracy. Fiction can tell the truth about the human condition because it can stage contradictions - dignity and degradation, hope and farce - without tidying them into a conclusion. Ellison argues that the only way to meet “here and now” is with art bold enough to be strange.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List
