"There never was any heart truly great and generous, that was not also tender and compassionate"
About this Quote
Greatness, Frost implies, isn’t a hard shell; it’s a porous one. The line pushes back against a familiar American fantasy of the “strong” person as emotionally armoured, a figure whose largeness of spirit comes packaged with stoicism or even bluntness. Frost argues the opposite: the truly “great and generous” heart must also be “tender and compassionate,” not as a sentimental add-on but as proof of authenticity. Generosity without tenderness can look like ego in a tuxedo - a performance of largesse that keeps the giver safely above the receiver.
The sentence is built like a moral stress test. “Never was any” sets an uncompromising standard, while “truly” narrows the definition of greatness to something inward and verifiable only by conduct. Frost’s pairing matters: “tender” suggests vulnerability and responsiveness, the willingness to be affected; “compassionate” suggests action, the willingness to move toward suffering rather than away from it. Together they frame empathy as both feeling and practice.
Contextually, Frost’s poetry often stages toughness (stone walls, winter woods, labor, restraint) and then quietly reveals the emotional costs of that toughness. This aphoristic line reads like the ethical thesis behind those scenes: the New England posture of reserve can’t be the final virtue. If you want the moral authority of “greatness,” Frost insists, you don’t get to skip the soft parts. Tenderness isn’t weakness; it’s the price of admission for any generosity worth trusting.
The sentence is built like a moral stress test. “Never was any” sets an uncompromising standard, while “truly” narrows the definition of greatness to something inward and verifiable only by conduct. Frost’s pairing matters: “tender” suggests vulnerability and responsiveness, the willingness to be affected; “compassionate” suggests action, the willingness to move toward suffering rather than away from it. Together they frame empathy as both feeling and practice.
Contextually, Frost’s poetry often stages toughness (stone walls, winter woods, labor, restraint) and then quietly reveals the emotional costs of that toughness. This aphoristic line reads like the ethical thesis behind those scenes: the New England posture of reserve can’t be the final virtue. If you want the moral authority of “greatness,” Frost insists, you don’t get to skip the soft parts. Tenderness isn’t weakness; it’s the price of admission for any generosity worth trusting.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List






