"There was never in my mind a desire to give in on the subject of freeing the political prisoners"
About this Quote
Bourassa’s line is built like a locked door: plain, firm, and meant to be tested. “There was never in my mind a desire to give in” is less a celebration of principle than a preemptive rebuttal to the central accusation that hovers over any leader in a crisis - that negotiation equals weakness. The phrase “in my mind” matters. It relocates the battleground from policy to character, asking the public to judge resolve rather than outcome. He’s not arguing the mechanics of a decision; he’s asserting an interior steadiness.
The loaded hinge is “give in.” Releasing “political prisoners” could be framed as justice, reconciliation, even de-escalation. Bourassa chooses the language of surrender, not reform. That’s intentional: it casts the opposing side as coercive, not political; it implies that the prisoners are bargaining chips in a contest of legitimacy. In that framing, freeing them isn’t mercy or due process - it’s capitulation that invites more demands.
Context sharpens the stakes. In Quebec’s era of high nationalist tension and, at moments, outright violence, Bourassa had to speak simultaneously to a frightened mainstream, to civil libertarians wary of state overreach, and to hardliners who wanted a show of force. This sentence is designed for broadcast: brief enough for headlines, absolute enough to anchor a narrative of control. Its subtext is state authority under pressure: the government will not be seen as governable by threat, even if the moral complexity of “political prisoners” sits, deliberately unresolved, in the background.
The loaded hinge is “give in.” Releasing “political prisoners” could be framed as justice, reconciliation, even de-escalation. Bourassa chooses the language of surrender, not reform. That’s intentional: it casts the opposing side as coercive, not political; it implies that the prisoners are bargaining chips in a contest of legitimacy. In that framing, freeing them isn’t mercy or due process - it’s capitulation that invites more demands.
Context sharpens the stakes. In Quebec’s era of high nationalist tension and, at moments, outright violence, Bourassa had to speak simultaneously to a frightened mainstream, to civil libertarians wary of state overreach, and to hardliners who wanted a show of force. This sentence is designed for broadcast: brief enough for headlines, absolute enough to anchor a narrative of control. Its subtext is state authority under pressure: the government will not be seen as governable by threat, even if the moral complexity of “political prisoners” sits, deliberately unresolved, in the background.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List





