"There were exceptions, a couple of families that just plain didn't want to even think about it, although forty years had passed but mostly the people were very interested in talking about it"
About this Quote
Memory is never evenly distributed; it pools where it’s safe and evaporates where it still burns. Walter Lord’s line catches that unevenness with the plainspoken steadiness of an oral historian who knows the real drama isn’t in what people remember, but in what they refuse to. The syntax rambles in a way that feels deliberate: thought follows thought, qualifiers pile up, and the sentence itself mimics the cautious approach of interviewing survivors and descendants. It’s a transcription of social atmosphere as much as content.
The telling friction is between “exceptions” and “mostly.” Lord concedes the holdouts without making them the story, then pivots to the broader hunger to speak. That imbalance is the point: collective tragedies don’t settle into silence; they ferment into narrative, anecdote, and moral accounting. The phrase “just plain didn’t want to even think about it” is vernacular, almost defensive. It implies not ignorance but active management - a family policy of containment. Then comes the quiet rebuke: “although forty years had passed.” Time is supposed to do the work of smoothing grief into history; Lord notes, with understated astonishment, that it doesn’t always.
Contextually, this is Lord the catastrophe chronicler (most famously of the Titanic) taking the temperature of a community decades later. He’s signaling the book’s method and its ethics: testimony is available, even abundant, but access is contingent on consent, and some wounds remain private property. The subtext is a challenge to the reader’s appetite for disaster stories: fascination is common; closure is optional.
The telling friction is between “exceptions” and “mostly.” Lord concedes the holdouts without making them the story, then pivots to the broader hunger to speak. That imbalance is the point: collective tragedies don’t settle into silence; they ferment into narrative, anecdote, and moral accounting. The phrase “just plain didn’t want to even think about it” is vernacular, almost defensive. It implies not ignorance but active management - a family policy of containment. Then comes the quiet rebuke: “although forty years had passed.” Time is supposed to do the work of smoothing grief into history; Lord notes, with understated astonishment, that it doesn’t always.
Contextually, this is Lord the catastrophe chronicler (most famously of the Titanic) taking the temperature of a community decades later. He’s signaling the book’s method and its ethics: testimony is available, even abundant, but access is contingent on consent, and some wounds remain private property. The subtext is a challenge to the reader’s appetite for disaster stories: fascination is common; closure is optional.
Quote Details
| Topic | Legacy & Remembrance |
|---|
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List
