"There would be no society if living together depended upon understanding each other"
About this Quote
Hoffer’s line lands like a slap to the idealists: society isn’t a book club where mutual comprehension is the entry fee. It’s a crowded bus. People share space, rules, and routines long before they share meanings. The specific intent is to puncture the liberal fantasy that social cohesion comes primarily from empathy or perfect communication. Hoffer, a longshoreman-philosopher who watched mass movements up close, is arguing that community is built less on understanding than on workable habits: tolerance, restraint, and the quiet decision not to make every difference a dealbreaker.
The subtext is almost mischievous. If we waited to “understand” one another - across class, religion, temperament, trauma, ideology - we’d never get past the first argument. Understanding is slow, partial, and often self-serving; it’s too fragile a foundation for something as blunt and necessary as coexistence. Hoffer is also hinting at the darker corollary: societies can function on misunderstanding, projection, even convenient stereotypes. People cooperate because incentives and institutions corral them, not because their inner lives line up.
Context matters: Hoffer wrote in an era shadowed by fascism, communism, and the mid-century American anxiety about conformity and belonging. His work repeatedly warns how easily humans trade nuance for certainty, especially in groups. The quote reads as a corrective to both utopian politics and interpersonal moralism. It doesn’t dismiss understanding as worthless; it demotes it. The real miracle, Hoffer implies, is not that we “get” each other, but that we keep showing up anyway.
The subtext is almost mischievous. If we waited to “understand” one another - across class, religion, temperament, trauma, ideology - we’d never get past the first argument. Understanding is slow, partial, and often self-serving; it’s too fragile a foundation for something as blunt and necessary as coexistence. Hoffer is also hinting at the darker corollary: societies can function on misunderstanding, projection, even convenient stereotypes. People cooperate because incentives and institutions corral them, not because their inner lives line up.
Context matters: Hoffer wrote in an era shadowed by fascism, communism, and the mid-century American anxiety about conformity and belonging. His work repeatedly warns how easily humans trade nuance for certainty, especially in groups. The quote reads as a corrective to both utopian politics and interpersonal moralism. It doesn’t dismiss understanding as worthless; it demotes it. The real miracle, Hoffer implies, is not that we “get” each other, but that we keep showing up anyway.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Eric
Add to List









