"Therefore it is essential that some means should be sought whereby the work of the nation may be carried on without constant yet at present necessary dislocation"
About this Quote
“Dislocation” is doing double duty here: it names the wrenching stoppages that labor militancy creates, and it quietly insists those stoppages are not aberrations but symptoms. Larkin, a union organizer who made his name in the lockouts and strikes that defined early 20th-century Irish labor politics, is speaking from inside a cycle where disruption is both weapon and inevitability. The line reads like a concession to the respectable ear - a nod to “the work of the nation” and the need for continuity - but the qualifier “yet at present necessary” refuses the moral scolding usually aimed at strikers. He’s not apologizing for disruption; he’s indicting the conditions that make it the only language employers and the state reliably hear.
The specific intent is strategic: to frame industrial unrest not as reckless agitation but as a rational response to an irrational system. By describing dislocation as “constant,” Larkin hints at a society running on periodic crisis, where stability is purchased by keeping workers powerless. The subtext is an invitation to choose: either build durable mechanisms - collective bargaining, labor protections, political representation - or accept recurring breakdowns as the price of ignoring inequality.
Even the bureaucratic phrasing (“some means should be sought whereby...”) matters. Larkin is meeting the language of governance on its own turf, translating strike energy into the vocabulary of national interest. It’s a pressure tactic in a suit: if the nation wants uninterrupted productivity, it must institutionalize justice rather than rely on exhaustion and emergency measures.
The specific intent is strategic: to frame industrial unrest not as reckless agitation but as a rational response to an irrational system. By describing dislocation as “constant,” Larkin hints at a society running on periodic crisis, where stability is purchased by keeping workers powerless. The subtext is an invitation to choose: either build durable mechanisms - collective bargaining, labor protections, political representation - or accept recurring breakdowns as the price of ignoring inequality.
Even the bureaucratic phrasing (“some means should be sought whereby...”) matters. Larkin is meeting the language of governance on its own turf, translating strike energy into the vocabulary of national interest. It’s a pressure tactic in a suit: if the nation wants uninterrupted productivity, it must institutionalize justice rather than rely on exhaustion and emergency measures.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List








