"There's an ancient tension between wanting to savor the world as it is and wanting to improve on the world as given"
About this Quote
Kass is naming a fault line that runs through modern life: the ache to be grateful and the itch to meddle. The line works because it refuses to flatter either side. “Savor” is sensual and moral at once, suggesting attention, reverence, even restraint. “Improve” carries the glow of progress but also the faint odor of arrogance. By calling the tension “ancient,” Kass frames it as something older than any culture war over tech, medicine, or education; it’s baked into how humans relate to nature, inheritance, and limits.
The subtext is a critique of the modern reflex to treat the given world as raw material. Kass, long associated with bioethics and skepticism toward certain biotechnologies, is gently prying apart two impulses that often get bundled together: care and control. To savor “the world as it is” isn’t complacency; it’s an ethic of gratitude that demands you notice what you’re about to overwrite. To want to “improve on the world as given” isn’t villainy; it’s the engine behind medicine, civil rights, and learning. The point is that both impulses can curdle: savoring becomes quietism, improvement becomes hubris.
Context matters: an educator and public intellectual arguing in an age of acceleration. The sentence is a speed bump for the reader’s conscience, forcing a pause before the next upgrade. Kass’s intent isn’t to stop change but to make progress answer to something thicker than novelty: humility toward what we didn’t invent and can’t fully understand.
The subtext is a critique of the modern reflex to treat the given world as raw material. Kass, long associated with bioethics and skepticism toward certain biotechnologies, is gently prying apart two impulses that often get bundled together: care and control. To savor “the world as it is” isn’t complacency; it’s an ethic of gratitude that demands you notice what you’re about to overwrite. To want to “improve on the world as given” isn’t villainy; it’s the engine behind medicine, civil rights, and learning. The point is that both impulses can curdle: savoring becomes quietism, improvement becomes hubris.
Context matters: an educator and public intellectual arguing in an age of acceleration. The sentence is a speed bump for the reader’s conscience, forcing a pause before the next upgrade. Kass’s intent isn’t to stop change but to make progress answer to something thicker than novelty: humility toward what we didn’t invent and can’t fully understand.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Leon
Add to List













