"There's nothing I like less than bad arguments for a view that I hold dear"
About this Quote
Few things expose a cause’s fragility faster than its own supporters arguing for it badly. Rose Kennedy’s line is a small etiquette lesson with a hard edge: she’s not criticizing opponents; she’s policing her side. The sting is in the intimacy of “a view that I hold dear.” This isn’t abstract debate-club scolding. It’s the particular disappointment of watching something you care about get turned into a sloppy talking point, a sentimental cliché, or a convenient excuse.
The intent is corrective, almost maternal, but also strategically cold. “Bad arguments” don’t just fail to persuade; they give adversaries ammunition, make the speaker look unserious, and quietly corrode the moral authority of the position itself. Kennedy’s phrasing implies a hierarchy of threats: a strong opposing case is less worrying than a weak friendly one, because it suggests the cause can’t stand on its best reasons.
The subtext is a warning about self-righteousness. When you “hold dear” a view, you’re tempted to treat conviction as proof. Kennedy rejects that shortcut. She separates loyalty from intellectual responsibility: you can be devoted and still demand rigor, even elegance, from the way devotion is expressed.
Context matters. Kennedy lived through an era when public life was family business, and messaging could be destiny. In a political dynasty, a single ill-formed defense can become the headline, the scandal, the caricature. Her sentence reads like a survival skill: if you want your values to endure in public, you don’t just need allies. You need competent advocates who don’t embarrass the truth.
The intent is corrective, almost maternal, but also strategically cold. “Bad arguments” don’t just fail to persuade; they give adversaries ammunition, make the speaker look unserious, and quietly corrode the moral authority of the position itself. Kennedy’s phrasing implies a hierarchy of threats: a strong opposing case is less worrying than a weak friendly one, because it suggests the cause can’t stand on its best reasons.
The subtext is a warning about self-righteousness. When you “hold dear” a view, you’re tempted to treat conviction as proof. Kennedy rejects that shortcut. She separates loyalty from intellectual responsibility: you can be devoted and still demand rigor, even elegance, from the way devotion is expressed.
Context matters. Kennedy lived through an era when public life was family business, and messaging could be destiny. In a political dynasty, a single ill-formed defense can become the headline, the scandal, the caricature. Her sentence reads like a survival skill: if you want your values to endure in public, you don’t just need allies. You need competent advocates who don’t embarrass the truth.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Rose
Add to List
