"There's nothing pretty about ice. Ice grows nothing. But we've got this in our minds that we've got to make everything cold"
About this Quote
Ice is a blunt metaphor: sterile, inert, impressive to look at, and quietly hostile to life. Don Young’s line works because it sounds like plainspoken Alaska talk while sneaking in a sharper accusation about modern governance. “Ice grows nothing” isn’t just geology; it’s an indictment of policies and attitudes that prize hardness over fertility, control over circulation, optics over outcomes. The phrase “nothing pretty” punctures the romantic postcard image of the North. He’s stripping away the tourist gaze and replacing it with lived reality: cold is not aesthetic, it’s an operating condition that kills crops, stalls development, and punishes the unprepared.
The pivot - “But we’ve got this in our minds” - shifts the target from climate to culture. Young is calling out a collective obsession with making things “cold”: emotionally, economically, politically. In political terms, “cold” reads as austerity, bureaucratic distance, technocratic detachment, and the way Washington can freeze local needs into abstract spreadsheets. It can also carry an environmental edge: the habit of engineering landscapes and systems as if they’re controllable machines rather than living ecosystems.
Context matters because Young’s brand was combative, populist, and deeply place-based. As Alaska’s long-serving congressman, he often framed national debates through frontier pragmatism: survival beats symbolism. The line is less a poetic musing than a warning from someone who’s seen what happens when you treat harshness as a virtue. Cold becomes an ideology, and ideology, like ice, doesn’t grow anything.
The pivot - “But we’ve got this in our minds” - shifts the target from climate to culture. Young is calling out a collective obsession with making things “cold”: emotionally, economically, politically. In political terms, “cold” reads as austerity, bureaucratic distance, technocratic detachment, and the way Washington can freeze local needs into abstract spreadsheets. It can also carry an environmental edge: the habit of engineering landscapes and systems as if they’re controllable machines rather than living ecosystems.
Context matters because Young’s brand was combative, populist, and deeply place-based. As Alaska’s long-serving congressman, he often framed national debates through frontier pragmatism: survival beats symbolism. The line is less a poetic musing than a warning from someone who’s seen what happens when you treat harshness as a virtue. Cold becomes an ideology, and ideology, like ice, doesn’t grow anything.
Quote Details
| Topic | Winter |
|---|
More Quotes by Don
Add to List
