"They have stolen the public lands. They have grasped all to themselves, and by their unprincipled greed brought a crisis of unparalleled distress on forty millions of people, who have natural resources to feed, clothe and shelter the whole human race"
About this Quote
Kearney’s line is a precision-engineered piece of late-19th-century populist fury: it starts with a theft narrative, widens into a moral indictment, then detonates into apocalyptic scale. “They have stolen the public lands” isn’t just a policy complaint; it frames economic inequality as a crime against common ownership, turning abstract dispossession into something prosecutable, something you can hate. The repetition of “They” creates a clean enemy class - faceless, unified, and therefore blameable - while “grasped” and “unprincipled greed” do the dirty work of making structural change feel like personal villainy.
The subtext is coalition-building through outrage. Kearney offers working people an explanation that’s emotionally satisfying and politically useful: your hardship isn’t random, and it isn’t your fault; it’s the result of deliberate extraction by a small, illegitimate elite. The “crisis of unparalleled distress” on “forty millions” inflates the grievance to national proportions, recruiting the reader into a majority identity under siege.
Context matters: Kearney rose in San Francisco amid depression-era labor unrest, railroad monopolies, land speculation, and deep resentment toward financiers and corporate power. His rhetoric hits real targets - enclosure of public resources, political capture - but it also sets the stage for scapegoating. By describing abundance enough to “feed, clothe and shelter the whole human race,” he invokes a frontier myth of limitless plenty, implying that scarcity must be sabotage. That move is seductive: it promises that prosperity is not only possible but being withheld. It’s also dangerous, because once you accept sabotage as the story, you start shopping for saboteurs.
The subtext is coalition-building through outrage. Kearney offers working people an explanation that’s emotionally satisfying and politically useful: your hardship isn’t random, and it isn’t your fault; it’s the result of deliberate extraction by a small, illegitimate elite. The “crisis of unparalleled distress” on “forty millions” inflates the grievance to national proportions, recruiting the reader into a majority identity under siege.
Context matters: Kearney rose in San Francisco amid depression-era labor unrest, railroad monopolies, land speculation, and deep resentment toward financiers and corporate power. His rhetoric hits real targets - enclosure of public resources, political capture - but it also sets the stage for scapegoating. By describing abundance enough to “feed, clothe and shelter the whole human race,” he invokes a frontier myth of limitless plenty, implying that scarcity must be sabotage. That move is seductive: it promises that prosperity is not only possible but being withheld. It’s also dangerous, because once you accept sabotage as the story, you start shopping for saboteurs.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Denis
Add to List
