"They that will not be counseled, cannot be helped. If you do not hear reason she will rap you on the knuckles"
About this Quote
Fowler’s line snaps like a ruler on a classroom desk: you can ignore advice, but you can’t ignore consequences. It’s a journalist’s distillation of human stubbornness into two brisk clauses, then a punchline that turns “reason” into a no-nonsense schoolmarm. That personification matters. Fowler isn’t pleading for rationality as some lofty ideal; he’s warning that rationality is an external force that shows up as pain when you refuse the gentler option. The knuckle-rap is comic, almost quaint, which is precisely why it lands: it makes punishment feel inevitable, even a little deserved, without tipping into melodrama.
The intent is moral but not sanctimonious. “They that will not be counseled” frames the problem as willful, not ignorant. You’re not lacking information; you’re refusing it. That’s a subtle indictment of pride and self-mythology, the kind Fowler would have watched up close in politics, show business, and newsrooms where bad decisions are often defended as personality. The sentence “cannot be helped” is colder than it looks: it suggests a limit to empathy, to institutions, even to friendship. Help requires consent.
Contextually, Fowler wrote in an era that prized the brisk epigram and distrusted grand theories. The quote carries that early-20th-century American pragmatism: reason isn’t a debate you win; it’s gravity. Ignore it, and the lesson arrives on schedule, tapping the same tender spot every time.
The intent is moral but not sanctimonious. “They that will not be counseled” frames the problem as willful, not ignorant. You’re not lacking information; you’re refusing it. That’s a subtle indictment of pride and self-mythology, the kind Fowler would have watched up close in politics, show business, and newsrooms where bad decisions are often defended as personality. The sentence “cannot be helped” is colder than it looks: it suggests a limit to empathy, to institutions, even to friendship. Help requires consent.
Contextually, Fowler wrote in an era that prized the brisk epigram and distrusted grand theories. The quote carries that early-20th-century American pragmatism: reason isn’t a debate you win; it’s gravity. Ignore it, and the lesson arrives on schedule, tapping the same tender spot every time.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Gene
Add to List




