"They told me I had been sick twelve days, lying like dead all the while, and that Whirlwind Chaser, who was Standing Bear's uncle and a medicine man, had brought me back to life"
About this Quote
Death here isn’t metaphor; it’s a report, delivered with the spare clarity of someone for whom the boundary between body and spirit is porous, negotiable. Black Elk’s sentence opens on a jarring passive construction: “They told me.” His own experience is partly inaccessible, reconstructed through community testimony. That detail matters. In Lakota life, authority doesn’t only come from private interiority; it’s conferred, witnessed, and narrated by others. The self is not a sealed room.
“Lying like dead” lands with a blunt simile that refuses prettification. The phrase carries the terror of illness in a world where sickness isn’t just biological failure but spiritual dislocation, a sign that something has slipped out of alignment. Then comes the pivot: Whirlwind Chaser, named like a force of weather, arrives with a role that is both familial (“Standing Bear’s uncle”) and institutional (“a medicine man”). Black Elk is quietly doing credentialing. This isn’t a random miracle; it’s a culturally legible act performed by someone whose kin ties and ceremonial expertise make the event believable inside the community’s moral universe.
The context is also political, even when it doesn’t announce itself. Black Elk’s life spans the U.S. conquest of the Plains, the suppression of ceremonies, and the long project of reducing Indigenous reality to “folklore.” By recording a resurrection-as-restoration without apology, he insists on a Lakota framework for causality and care. The subtext: survival is not only staying alive; it’s being brought back into relation, by people who still know how.
“Lying like dead” lands with a blunt simile that refuses prettification. The phrase carries the terror of illness in a world where sickness isn’t just biological failure but spiritual dislocation, a sign that something has slipped out of alignment. Then comes the pivot: Whirlwind Chaser, named like a force of weather, arrives with a role that is both familial (“Standing Bear’s uncle”) and institutional (“a medicine man”). Black Elk is quietly doing credentialing. This isn’t a random miracle; it’s a culturally legible act performed by someone whose kin ties and ceremonial expertise make the event believable inside the community’s moral universe.
The context is also political, even when it doesn’t announce itself. Black Elk’s life spans the U.S. conquest of the Plains, the suppression of ceremonies, and the long project of reducing Indigenous reality to “folklore.” By recording a resurrection-as-restoration without apology, he insists on a Lakota framework for causality and care. The subtext: survival is not only staying alive; it’s being brought back into relation, by people who still know how.
Quote Details
| Topic | Native American Sayings |
|---|---|
| Source | Black Elk Speaks: Being the Life Story of a Holy Man of the Oglala Sioux, as told to John G. Neihardt (1932) — passage describing Black Elk's sickness and revival by the medicine man Whirlwind Chaser. |
More Quotes by Black
Add to List
