"They were nothing like the French people I had imagined. If anything, they were too kind, too generous and too knowledgable in the fields of plumbing and electricity"
About this Quote
Sedaris takes the tourist fantasy of France - all aloof waiters, elegant disdain, chic suffering - and punctures it with the least romantic punchline imaginable: plumbing and electricity. The move is classic Sedaris: he starts with a familiar prejudice ("the French people I had imagined") and then flips it into an overcorrection so absurdly specific it exposes the original bias as lazy storytelling. "If anything" is doing sly work here, pretending to be fair-minded while steering us straight into the joke.
The line also skewers how Americans often shop for foreignness like a curated experience. Sedaris wants a certain France, one that confirms a prepackaged narrative of rudeness or sophistication. Instead he gets competence and kindness - the mundane virtues you never put on a postcard. By calling them "too kind, too generous", he mocks his own disappointment at being denied the drama of cultural friction. It's not that generosity is bad; it's that it ruins the bit.
The specificity of "plumbing and electricity" is the real tell. It drags lofty cultural expectation down to bodily, domestic reality: leaky pipes, flickering lights, the unglamorous infrastructure that makes life livable. Sedaris is quietly praising the people who actually keep a place running, while satirizing the traveler who arrives seeking aesthetic stereotypes rather than human beings. The subtext lands: your fantasies about a country say more about your needs than about the country itself.
The line also skewers how Americans often shop for foreignness like a curated experience. Sedaris wants a certain France, one that confirms a prepackaged narrative of rudeness or sophistication. Instead he gets competence and kindness - the mundane virtues you never put on a postcard. By calling them "too kind, too generous", he mocks his own disappointment at being denied the drama of cultural friction. It's not that generosity is bad; it's that it ruins the bit.
The specificity of "plumbing and electricity" is the real tell. It drags lofty cultural expectation down to bodily, domestic reality: leaky pipes, flickering lights, the unglamorous infrastructure that makes life livable. Sedaris is quietly praising the people who actually keep a place running, while satirizing the traveler who arrives seeking aesthetic stereotypes rather than human beings. The subtext lands: your fantasies about a country say more about your needs than about the country itself.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by David
Add to List
