"They who drink beer will think beer"
About this Quote
A puritanical joke dressed up as worldly observation, Irving's line lands because it pretends to be a simple proverb while quietly policing taste. "They who drink beer will think beer" isn't really about beverages; it's about mental diet. The sentence is engineered like a moral law: drink X, become X. No qualifiers, no nuance, just a brisk cause-and-effect that flatters the speaker as someone above the fog of the taproom.
Irving was a writer who made a career out of manners and masks, and you can hear that sensibility here. The phrasing carries the old-world cadence of a maxim, but the target is modern and democratic: ordinary people, ordinary pleasures, the suspicion that mass indulgence produces mass-mindedness. Beer stands in for anything convivial and a little blunt - the kind of social glue that also dulls the edge of refinement. The subtext is class-coded: you can almost feel the raised eyebrow at the hearty drinker whose ideas, like his drink, are presumed heavy, brown, and common.
Placed in the early 19th-century Anglo-American world, the line also nods at temperance-era anxieties without preaching like a reform pamphlet. Irving's restraint is the trick. He doesn't condemn drunkenness; he mocks the imagination that settles for what's on tap. It's a writer's warning, too: consume the same stuff every day and your inner life starts to rhyme with it.
Irving was a writer who made a career out of manners and masks, and you can hear that sensibility here. The phrasing carries the old-world cadence of a maxim, but the target is modern and democratic: ordinary people, ordinary pleasures, the suspicion that mass indulgence produces mass-mindedness. Beer stands in for anything convivial and a little blunt - the kind of social glue that also dulls the edge of refinement. The subtext is class-coded: you can almost feel the raised eyebrow at the hearty drinker whose ideas, like his drink, are presumed heavy, brown, and common.
Placed in the early 19th-century Anglo-American world, the line also nods at temperance-era anxieties without preaching like a reform pamphlet. Irving's restraint is the trick. He doesn't condemn drunkenness; he mocks the imagination that settles for what's on tap. It's a writer's warning, too: consume the same stuff every day and your inner life starts to rhyme with it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Washington
Add to List

