"They're simply following what was laid down in front and they play the same thing. So, there's no great challenge In being a classical drummer"
About this Quote
Buddy Rich is doing what great bandstand trash-talkers do: taking a knife to the idea of “serious” music by aiming at its most protected symbol, classical tradition. On the surface, he’s dismissing classical percussion as paint-by-numbers - read what’s written, hit what’s marked, collect your applause. The real target is cultural prestige: the way “classical” gets treated as inherently harder, purer, more legitimate than the messy, vernacular genius of jazz.
Rich’s intent is partly territorial. As a virtuoso who made his reputation on speed, control, and risk, he’s arguing that challenge isn’t just technical execution; it’s improvisational decision-making under pressure. In jazz, the drummer isn’t a metronome in a tuxedo, they’re a co-author. You shape time, you provoke soloists, you steer a band through chaos without a safety net. His subtext: if the notes are fixed, the job becomes reproduction, not creation.
There’s also an ego-and-era context that matters. Rich came up when jazz musicians were routinely treated as entertainers rather than artists, even while doing some of the most sophisticated rhythmic work on the planet. His jab flips that hierarchy. Of course, it’s exaggerated - orchestral percussion demands precision, ensemble diplomacy, and a different kind of nerve. But the exaggeration is the point: it’s a provocation meant to defend the value of swing, spontaneity, and authorship in a culture that often confuses “written down” with “better.”
Rich’s intent is partly territorial. As a virtuoso who made his reputation on speed, control, and risk, he’s arguing that challenge isn’t just technical execution; it’s improvisational decision-making under pressure. In jazz, the drummer isn’t a metronome in a tuxedo, they’re a co-author. You shape time, you provoke soloists, you steer a band through chaos without a safety net. His subtext: if the notes are fixed, the job becomes reproduction, not creation.
There’s also an ego-and-era context that matters. Rich came up when jazz musicians were routinely treated as entertainers rather than artists, even while doing some of the most sophisticated rhythmic work on the planet. His jab flips that hierarchy. Of course, it’s exaggerated - orchestral percussion demands precision, ensemble diplomacy, and a different kind of nerve. But the exaggeration is the point: it’s a provocation meant to defend the value of swing, spontaneity, and authorship in a culture that often confuses “written down” with “better.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Buddy
Add to List

