"This Budget reflects a choice - not an easy choice, but the right choice. And when you think about it, the only choice. The choice to take the responsible, prudent path to fiscal stability, economic growth and opportunity"
About this Quote
Pataki’s genius here is in making austerity sound like destiny. He opens with the language of conscience - “not an easy choice, but the right choice” - a familiar political move that launders pain into virtue. If it hurts, the logic goes, it must be responsible. Then comes the rhetorical trapdoor: “the only choice.” Once you accept that framing, debate becomes childish. Opponents aren’t offering an alternative plan; they’re refusing reality.
The line is built on a careful balancing act between moralizing and reassurance. “Responsible” and “prudent” are character words, not policy words. They imply that fiscal decisions are tests of adulthood rather than contests of values. That’s the subtext: budgets aren’t just spreadsheets, they’re proof of who is serious enough to govern. It’s also a preemptive strike against criticism from constituencies likely to lose out. Cuts and constraints are reframed as the unavoidable price of “stability,” a term that flatters anxious voters and nervous markets alike.
Context matters: Pataki governed New York through the 1990s-era pivot toward balanced-budget politics and tax-cut centrism, then into the post-9/11 climate where public spending pressures and security demands collided. “Fiscal stability, economic growth and opportunity” is a trilogy meant to reconcile contradictions: tighten now, prosper later, and trust that the benefits will feel broadly shared. The sentence sells a contested ideology - smaller government discipline - as common sense, turning politics into an allegedly apolitical “path.”
The line is built on a careful balancing act between moralizing and reassurance. “Responsible” and “prudent” are character words, not policy words. They imply that fiscal decisions are tests of adulthood rather than contests of values. That’s the subtext: budgets aren’t just spreadsheets, they’re proof of who is serious enough to govern. It’s also a preemptive strike against criticism from constituencies likely to lose out. Cuts and constraints are reframed as the unavoidable price of “stability,” a term that flatters anxious voters and nervous markets alike.
Context matters: Pataki governed New York through the 1990s-era pivot toward balanced-budget politics and tax-cut centrism, then into the post-9/11 climate where public spending pressures and security demands collided. “Fiscal stability, economic growth and opportunity” is a trilogy meant to reconcile contradictions: tighten now, prosper later, and trust that the benefits will feel broadly shared. The sentence sells a contested ideology - smaller government discipline - as common sense, turning politics into an allegedly apolitical “path.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by George
Add to List

