"This business switching styles can't be done honestly by one man. As soon as he can play his instrument well, he can express himself, and all his life he has only one self"
About this Quote
Rushing is throwing a velvet-gloved punch at the idea that a musician can slip between styles like changing jackets. Coming out of the big band era - and as one of Count Basie's defining voices - he knew that what audiences call "style" is really biography: the grain of your timing, the way you lean into a phrase, the community you learned it in, the nights you survived to earn it. His claim that switching styles "can't be done honestly" isn't purist snobbery as much as a warning against musical tourism, the kind that treats traditions as interchangeable effects.
The line turns on a quiet paradox: mastery liberates you, but it also pins you down. "As soon as he can play his instrument well, he can express himself" suggests that technique is not neutral; once the instrument stops fighting you, your instincts start showing. Expression is exposure. And exposure reveals that you only have "one self" - not one genre, but one set of reflexes: your touch, your sense of swing, your emotional defaults. You can mimic surfaces, but you can't counterfeit where the music comes from without the performance turning into costume.
There's also a practical, era-specific edge. Mid-century jazz was already being packaged, categorized, and marketed. Rushing pushes back on the industry temptation to rebrand artists on demand. His subtext is almost ethical: authenticity isn't a vibe, it's a history. If you chase every fashionable sound, you risk losing the one thing that can't be replaced - the signature that makes a player worth hearing in the first place.
The line turns on a quiet paradox: mastery liberates you, but it also pins you down. "As soon as he can play his instrument well, he can express himself" suggests that technique is not neutral; once the instrument stops fighting you, your instincts start showing. Expression is exposure. And exposure reveals that you only have "one self" - not one genre, but one set of reflexes: your touch, your sense of swing, your emotional defaults. You can mimic surfaces, but you can't counterfeit where the music comes from without the performance turning into costume.
There's also a practical, era-specific edge. Mid-century jazz was already being packaged, categorized, and marketed. Rushing pushes back on the industry temptation to rebrand artists on demand. His subtext is almost ethical: authenticity isn't a vibe, it's a history. If you chase every fashionable sound, you risk losing the one thing that can't be replaced - the signature that makes a player worth hearing in the first place.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Jimmy
Add to List







