"This can not be about a race to the bottom"
About this Quote
The line lands like a hand on the emergency brake: stop treating decline as strategy. Alexis Herman, a public servant who came up through Democratic labor and economic policy circles and later served as Secretary of Labor, is speaking in the clipped moral grammar of governance. “Can not” isn’t casual pessimism; it’s a boundary-setting phrase, a refusal to accept the framing that the only way to compete is to surrender standards.
The “race” metaphor does quiet work. It implies rivals, spectators, and an agreed-upon course, which is exactly what Herman is disputing. If public policy is reduced to a competitive sprint, then the winner is whoever can shed the most obligations fastest: wages, workplace protections, environmental rules, taxes, even basic accountability. That’s the “bottom” she’s pointing at, a destination marketed as efficiency but experienced as precarity.
Her specific intent is to shift the debate from short-term cost cutting to long-term legitimacy: prosperity that depends on weaker workers and thinner public goods isn’t prosperity, it’s extraction with better branding. The subtext is also political: in an era of globalization and deregulation talk, “race to the bottom” names a familiar trap where leaders claim their hands are tied by markets, while actively choosing to tie them.
What makes the quote work is its compact indictment of inevitability. Herman doesn’t argue policy details; she challenges the story people tell to excuse them. If you accept the race, you accept the bottom. She’s insisting the nation can choose a different contest: competing upward on skill, innovation, and shared standards rather than shared sacrifice by the least powerful.
The “race” metaphor does quiet work. It implies rivals, spectators, and an agreed-upon course, which is exactly what Herman is disputing. If public policy is reduced to a competitive sprint, then the winner is whoever can shed the most obligations fastest: wages, workplace protections, environmental rules, taxes, even basic accountability. That’s the “bottom” she’s pointing at, a destination marketed as efficiency but experienced as precarity.
Her specific intent is to shift the debate from short-term cost cutting to long-term legitimacy: prosperity that depends on weaker workers and thinner public goods isn’t prosperity, it’s extraction with better branding. The subtext is also political: in an era of globalization and deregulation talk, “race to the bottom” names a familiar trap where leaders claim their hands are tied by markets, while actively choosing to tie them.
What makes the quote work is its compact indictment of inevitability. Herman doesn’t argue policy details; she challenges the story people tell to excuse them. If you accept the race, you accept the bottom. She’s insisting the nation can choose a different contest: competing upward on skill, innovation, and shared standards rather than shared sacrifice by the least powerful.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Alexis
Add to List
