"This implies that the laws governing organic cohesion, the organization leading from the part to the whole, represent a biological uncertainty, indeed an uncertainty of the first order"
About this Quote
Walter Rudolf Hess points to a profound limit in biological understanding: the rules that bind living parts into coherent wholes are not crisp mechanical laws but patterns laced with irreducible uncertainty. Organic cohesion refers to the way cells, tissues, and circuits integrate their activities so that a body behaves as a unified organism. When the organization proceeds from the part to the whole, the resulting behavior cannot be derived by simple addition; it emerges from interactions, feedbacks, and context. Calling this a first-order uncertainty signals that the indeterminacy is not a mere measurement error or a temporary gap in knowledge, but an intrinsic feature of living systems.
Hess earned the Nobel Prize for mapping hypothalamic functions by stimulating tiny brain regions and observing complex, coordinated responses: changes in blood pressure and heart rate, patterns of grooming or aggressive postures, shifts in breathing, facial expressions, and visceral states. Such experiments showed that a small local perturbation could trigger a global pattern, and that the pattern depended on the organism’s internal state and prior history. The same stimulus could yield different outcomes, and the whole could not be predicted reliably from the part in isolation. That is biological uncertainty in action.
Unlike engineered machines where component behavior composes neatly, organisms operate through nested networks with nonlinear couplings, redundancy, and degeneracy. Feedback loops cross scales, from gene expression to autonomic regulation, so cause and effect blur into circular causation. Development and homeostasis are robust yet plastic, using noise as a resource rather than a nuisance. The regularities we can formulate are therefore statistical, conditional, and system-level.
Hess’s observation urges humility about reductionism and a turn toward integrative approaches that model constraints and possibilities rather than fixed trajectories. It foreshadows systems biology and dynamical views in which phase changes, thresholds, and context determine outcomes. The lawfulness of life lives alongside first-order uncertainty, and meaningful explanation must honor both.
Hess earned the Nobel Prize for mapping hypothalamic functions by stimulating tiny brain regions and observing complex, coordinated responses: changes in blood pressure and heart rate, patterns of grooming or aggressive postures, shifts in breathing, facial expressions, and visceral states. Such experiments showed that a small local perturbation could trigger a global pattern, and that the pattern depended on the organism’s internal state and prior history. The same stimulus could yield different outcomes, and the whole could not be predicted reliably from the part in isolation. That is biological uncertainty in action.
Unlike engineered machines where component behavior composes neatly, organisms operate through nested networks with nonlinear couplings, redundancy, and degeneracy. Feedback loops cross scales, from gene expression to autonomic regulation, so cause and effect blur into circular causation. Development and homeostasis are robust yet plastic, using noise as a resource rather than a nuisance. The regularities we can formulate are therefore statistical, conditional, and system-level.
Hess’s observation urges humility about reductionism and a turn toward integrative approaches that model constraints and possibilities rather than fixed trajectories. It foreshadows systems biology and dynamical views in which phase changes, thresholds, and context determine outcomes. The lawfulness of life lives alongside first-order uncertainty, and meaningful explanation must honor both.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List
