"This is my truth, tell me yours"
About this Quote
Aneurin Bevan’s line lands like an invitation, but it’s really a dare. “This is my truth, tell me yours” sounds soft-edged in today’s self-care idiom, yet from the architect of the NHS it reads as political jujitsu: he offers “my truth” not as a retreat into private feeling but as a public wager, then forces the listener to step out from behind slogans. It’s an accountability trap disguised as civility.
The phrasing is doing double work. “This is” has the bluntness of testimony, not theory. “My truth” concedes perspective without surrendering conviction; it sidesteps the easy caricature of opponents as simply evil or stupid, while still implying that arguments should be anchored in lived reality, material conditions, and consequences. Then comes the pivot: “tell me yours.” Bevan shifts the burden of proof. If you’re going to oppose his project of social democracy, you don’t get to hide in abstractions about “freedom” or “efficiency.” Name the world you’re defending. Who pays, who benefits, who gets left untreated?
That’s the Bevan context: postwar Britain, scarcity, class hierarchy, and the fierce fight to build a welfare state against entrenched interests, especially within medicine and the Conservative establishment. The subtext is that politics isn’t a debate club; it’s a collision of competing realities. By insisting on “yours,” he exposes the moral choices underneath policy talk and makes disagreement legible as a set of values, not just a difference of opinion.
The phrasing is doing double work. “This is” has the bluntness of testimony, not theory. “My truth” concedes perspective without surrendering conviction; it sidesteps the easy caricature of opponents as simply evil or stupid, while still implying that arguments should be anchored in lived reality, material conditions, and consequences. Then comes the pivot: “tell me yours.” Bevan shifts the burden of proof. If you’re going to oppose his project of social democracy, you don’t get to hide in abstractions about “freedom” or “efficiency.” Name the world you’re defending. Who pays, who benefits, who gets left untreated?
That’s the Bevan context: postwar Britain, scarcity, class hierarchy, and the fierce fight to build a welfare state against entrenched interests, especially within medicine and the Conservative establishment. The subtext is that politics isn’t a debate club; it’s a collision of competing realities. By insisting on “yours,” he exposes the moral choices underneath policy talk and makes disagreement legible as a set of values, not just a difference of opinion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Aneurin
Add to List











