"This is not the first time that Mexican authorities have handed over an Arab from a country with known Al Qaeda connections to a local sheriff across the border. FBI picks them up and disappears"
About this Quote
Culberson’s line is engineered to do two jobs at once: fuse border anxiety to terrorism fear, then outsource the messy details to a shadowy “they.” The construction is classic political insinuation. “This is not the first time” implies a pattern without offering verifiable instances, inviting the listener to fill in the blanks with whatever cable-news montage they already carry. “Mexican authorities” becomes a monolith, “an Arab” becomes a type, and “a country with known Al Qaeda connections” is a deliberately elastic phrase - suggestive enough to alarm, vague enough to dodge accountability.
The most telling move is jurisdictional theater. The handoff “to a local sheriff across the border” paints U.S. law enforcement as surprised and improvisational, as if the border is porous not just to people but to competence. Then the kicker: “FBI picks them up and disappears.” That verb is doing propaganda work. “Disappears” borrows the moral charge of authoritarian repression, flipping it onto a federal agency to imply secrecy, cover-up, or complicity. It invites conspiracy thinking while preserving plausible deniability: he’s not alleging misconduct outright, just gesturing at a fog of untraceable actions.
Contextually, this fits a post-9/11 political ecosystem where “terror” became a multiplier for every other policy argument, especially immigration enforcement and border funding. The subtext isn’t simply “be afraid.” It’s “trust local conservatives, distrust federal institutions, and treat certain identities as presumptive risk.” The intent is to harden public consent for aggressive border measures by making ambiguity feel like evidence.
The most telling move is jurisdictional theater. The handoff “to a local sheriff across the border” paints U.S. law enforcement as surprised and improvisational, as if the border is porous not just to people but to competence. Then the kicker: “FBI picks them up and disappears.” That verb is doing propaganda work. “Disappears” borrows the moral charge of authoritarian repression, flipping it onto a federal agency to imply secrecy, cover-up, or complicity. It invites conspiracy thinking while preserving plausible deniability: he’s not alleging misconduct outright, just gesturing at a fog of untraceable actions.
Contextually, this fits a post-9/11 political ecosystem where “terror” became a multiplier for every other policy argument, especially immigration enforcement and border funding. The subtext isn’t simply “be afraid.” It’s “trust local conservatives, distrust federal institutions, and treat certain identities as presumptive risk.” The intent is to harden public consent for aggressive border measures by making ambiguity feel like evidence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
