"This life is worth living, we can say, since it is what we make it"
About this Quote
James doesn’t offer comfort; he offers a job. “This life is worth living” arrives with a lawyerly hesitation - “we can say” - as if he’s daring the reader to notice how flimsy metaphysical certainty is. The pivot is the clause that follows: “since it is what we make it.” Worth isn’t discovered like a hidden property of the universe; it’s manufactured, maintained, revised. James is smuggling a whole philosophical rebellion into a sentence: stop waiting for cosmic guarantees, start acting as if meaning is a human craft.
That’s classic pragmatism, written in the shadow of Darwin and the late-19th-century crisis of faith. The old scaffolding (God, destiny, a fixed moral order) had started to look optional, even untenable, for educated moderns. James doesn’t try to rebuild it. He reframes the problem: if the universe won’t hand you purpose, the only test left is whether your beliefs and choices produce a life you can stand behind. “We” matters, too. This isn’t rugged individualism so much as a social wager: value is made collectively through work, relationships, institutions, and habits. A life becomes “worth” something because we treat certain things as worth doing, then build worlds where that treating has consequences.
The subtext is bracing and slightly bleak: if life feels pointless, that isn’t evidence against meaning; it’s evidence of unfinished construction. James’s intent is to turn existential anxiety into agency, replacing passive despair with the radical, unglamorous power of making.
That’s classic pragmatism, written in the shadow of Darwin and the late-19th-century crisis of faith. The old scaffolding (God, destiny, a fixed moral order) had started to look optional, even untenable, for educated moderns. James doesn’t try to rebuild it. He reframes the problem: if the universe won’t hand you purpose, the only test left is whether your beliefs and choices produce a life you can stand behind. “We” matters, too. This isn’t rugged individualism so much as a social wager: value is made collectively through work, relationships, institutions, and habits. A life becomes “worth” something because we treat certain things as worth doing, then build worlds where that treating has consequences.
The subtext is bracing and slightly bleak: if life feels pointless, that isn’t evidence against meaning; it’s evidence of unfinished construction. James’s intent is to turn existential anxiety into agency, replacing passive despair with the radical, unglamorous power of making.
Quote Details
| Topic | Meaning of Life |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List











