"This may sound trite, but bad things happen to good people, and when you're facing terrorism, natural disaster, you can have every wonderful plan in place, but I am a realist"
About this Quote
Trite is doing a lot of work here: Rudman leads with the apology not because he doubts the point, but because he knows how a certain kind of public talk collapses into cliches when it brushes up against catastrophe. The line is built like a preemptive strike against optimism-as-policy. By conceding the banality up front, he clears space to say something politically risky in an American context: planning is necessary, but it is not sovereign.
The intent is managerial and moral at once. “Bad things happen to good people” sounds like a Hallmark shrug, yet in Rudman’s mouth it functions as a refusal of blame narratives that often follow terrorism or disasters. After trauma, voters and media go hunting for the single preventable failure, the villain who “should’ve seen it coming.” Rudman is resisting that instinct. He’s also setting expectations: don’t confuse preparedness with invulnerability, and don’t treat government like an insurance policy that pays out in certainty.
The phrase “every wonderful plan” is a quiet dig at technocratic overconfidence, the belief that the right binder, the right agency chart, the right tabletop exercise can domesticate chaos. Listing “terrorism” and “natural disaster” in the same breath situates human malice and indifferent nature as twin tests of the state’s limits. The closer is the tell: “I am a realist” is both self-branding and a demand that the audience adopt his posture. Realism here isn’t cynicism; it’s political consent for the messy truth that security is always partial, and accountability should be smarter than scapegoating.
The intent is managerial and moral at once. “Bad things happen to good people” sounds like a Hallmark shrug, yet in Rudman’s mouth it functions as a refusal of blame narratives that often follow terrorism or disasters. After trauma, voters and media go hunting for the single preventable failure, the villain who “should’ve seen it coming.” Rudman is resisting that instinct. He’s also setting expectations: don’t confuse preparedness with invulnerability, and don’t treat government like an insurance policy that pays out in certainty.
The phrase “every wonderful plan” is a quiet dig at technocratic overconfidence, the belief that the right binder, the right agency chart, the right tabletop exercise can domesticate chaos. Listing “terrorism” and “natural disaster” in the same breath situates human malice and indifferent nature as twin tests of the state’s limits. The closer is the tell: “I am a realist” is both self-branding and a demand that the audience adopt his posture. Realism here isn’t cynicism; it’s political consent for the messy truth that security is always partial, and accountability should be smarter than scapegoating.
Quote Details
| Topic | Tough Times |
|---|
More Quotes by Warren
Add to List





